Two McHenry High School Board Candidates Address Wonder Lake Voters

David Yang sits at the head table in front of a "Don't Tread on Me" flag.

McHenry Citizens Tax Watch, a new group springing out of Wonder Lake founded by Bob Anderson and David Yang, held a meeting Sunday afternoon at Christ the King Catholic Church.

It was a bifurcated one featuring National Taxpayers United of Illinois’ Jim Tobin and his daughter Christina, now a Vice President of her father’s group, plus two candidates for the McHenry High School Board.

I’ll concentrate on the latter today, since defeat of the high school’s referendum next month is one of the reasons the group was founded.

Wonder Lake's Bob Anderson led the meeting.

Anderson, who moderated the meeting in back of a Vote NO yard sign, told the audience that the group was concentrating on not only


  • defeating this second time around attempt to hike taxes (after a 73% loss last fall), but also
  • convincing legislators not to allow such repeat referendums, plus
  • ending the right of teachers to strike and
  • supporting the “3 in a Row” slate, all of whose candidates “have assured me they won’t support the tax increase.”

“I’ll be supporting them,” Anderson declared.

Beth Taylor and Steve Bellmore, two members of the “3 in a Row” slate, gave opening statements and answered questions.

Let me give you a flavor of what went on.

Steven Bellmore

First Bellmore:

“When the School Board threatened to cut Advanced Placement, extra curricular, co-curricular and sports, I said, ‘Enough is enough!’

“We’ve had money in there to the tune of $25 million that’s basically disappeared.”

He argued for more transparency, decrying “their lack of candidness with the community.”

“You can’t spend money you don’t have,” he added.

Taylor explained,

Beth Taylor

“I got fired up to run about the same time Steve did.”

She told of attending a meeting called by the School Board last fall where four choices were outlined.

“The School Board chose the third worst.  It would have made high school a miserable experience.

“They sprang it without warning.

“Where are we going to be two to three years from now?”

Asked about what concessions the group was seeking, mention in the pamphlet published here Sunday, Bellmore said they would be looking to both the administration and teachers.

He pointed out that salaries had gone up 48% over five years in McHenry, while fringe benefits had increased 59%.

Bellmore compare that to salary increases of 18% in Johnsburg and 8% in Richmond-Burton. Fringe benefit increases there had been 9% and 4% over the five year period.

‘Why the disparity?” he asked.

So what concessions does he seek?

“A three-year hard freeze on salaries and concessions on benefits.”

Bellmore said that McHenry High School teachers paid nothing for their own health insurance and their families got an 85% subsidy.

Steve Bellmore holds up "3 in a Row" yard sign. Beth Taylor is on his left and Bob Anderson can be seen in the background.

That compares to Crystal Lake District 155’s 100% payment of teacher health benefits and 50% for family coverage. In Johnsburg and Richmond, teachers have to pay 15% of their own health insurance cost and all of their family’s coverage.

“Is this going to balance the budget?

“No. It’s a start.

“Is there a need for scalebacks for classes and extra-curriculars?

“Probably,” but he noted, “They’ve already made scalebacks.”

Bellmore talked about meetings of the current school board:
“You go to these meetings and you get no answers.”

About future tax hikes: “If you want to pass a referendum, you need to communicate with (the community first).

“Right now, if we don’t have the money, you don’t spend it.”

At this point, Anderson asked,

“Are you going to be voting, ‘No?'”

Beth Taylor holds up the "3 in a Row" slate's pamhlet, which was published on McHenry County Blog, Sunday, March 13th.

Both Bellmore and Taylor answered, “Yes.”

Anderson revealed that he had talked to the third member of the slate, Timothy Byers, and he had made the same commitment.

“Everyone’s done with less,” Bellmore added. “I’m down 60% in my business.

“Teachers are important. I think the teachers here are quality.”

An audience member asked about the four options offered by the school board last fall.

Taylor explained that the worst was to close East High School and put the students on double shifts at West.

“Option three would have had an open campus at lunch with twenty-five teachers down,” she continued.

“They would be late, if they came back at all.”

She added that there would be no dances and rattled off a list of other extracurricular activities that would have disappeared.

The audience members pointed out that businessmen were regularly making 5-10% concessions.

A man asked whether any of the options had anything about concessions.

“The concessions on the salary end are cutting this many teachers,” Taylor said.

“It’s get rid of the new ones, the ones with fire in their bellies.”

A man observed that in the business world “people are taking 5-10% concessions.”

Taylor said, “The problem is that a lot of teachers are married to teachers. They are living in a bubble (isolated from what’s happening to other families).”

Someone wondered if negotiations might result in a strike.

“Possibly,” Taylor replied.

“If they refuse concessions, there may be a strike” Bellmore said. “There’s a lot of people out of work out there…We need a strong school board.

“In my mind, I’m watching out for the kids first. If you build trust with the community, you’re going to have trust with the community.”

McHenry East High School from the street where the new TIF-subsidized condominiums were built.

There was a question about the East High School’s new gym being built one-foot short. The implication from the audience was that this was a deliberate attempt to make East easier to close.

Taylor reacted by pointing out the absurdity of the state’s requiring 8o acres for new schools.

“I don’t think a new school makes smarter kids.”

Bellmore pointed out that since 2005 the district has added only 100 students, but hired 33 new staff. He did not know how many staff had left during that time, he admitted.

After the meeting, I asked Taylor about her having had a “Vote Yes” sign in front of her home last fall.

She told me she had two children in high school and was horrified at what the school board had proposed.

“I was thinking with my heart, not my head.”

The clear implication was that she was following her head this time around and it led her to the positions she enunciated.


Two McHenry High School Board Candidates Address Wonder Lake Voters — 2 Comments

  1. The candidates say on one hand – you can’t spend money you don’t have yet they demanded exactly that from the current school board. The current BOE committed to cuts that would have helped balance the budget. Whether the proposed cuts (elimination of 27.7 teachers and elimination of sports/co-curriculars) was the right thing to do or not is debatable but you can’t have it both ways. Mr. Bellmore acknowledges that concessions won’t balance the budget and cuts will need to be made. What cuts is he proposing we make?

    Also – if you listen specifically to Mr. Byer’s interview on the NW Herald – he is not opposed to new taxes. In fact the group he is affiliated with will go out and promote a referendum if teacher’s make concessions. Sorry Mr. Andersen – you are being duped.

  2. Update from the April 2011 election.

    From on April 6, 2011.

    In a rare school board upset, the incumbents lost.

    Tim Byers 4,994 votes (Citizens for Fiscal Responsibility slate)
    Steve Bellmore 4,788 votes (Citizens for Fiscal Responsibility slate)
    Beth Taylor 5,040 votes (Citizens for Fiscal Responsibility slate)
    Tracy Simon 1,226 votes (Citizens Alliance for Responsible Education slate)
    Stephen White 1,156 votes (Citizens Alliance for Responsible Education slate)
    Daniel Koruna 539 votes (incumbent)
    Mellody Ahrens 870 votes (incumbent)
    Alexandra Coy 524 votes (challenger)
    Darnell Qualls 339 votes (challenger)

    The challengers were against the bond referendum (which lost 6,054 votes to 1,177) and called for concessions from the district staff members.

    It would be interesting to attend the school board meetings to see the new dynamics, as the 3 challengers will have a minority in the 7 seat board.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *