McHenry County Blog

Subscribe

Archive for November 14th, 2011

Outback Steakhouse Replies to Tea Party Complaint

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Bracelet, Breakdown of America, Crystal Lake, Fired, Outback Steakhouse, TEA Party

A photo the protestors at Crystal Lake Outback Steakhouse sent yesterday. "Fired for a bracelet. HONK -4- Free Speech."

Yesterday, this story was posted from information provided by McHenry County Blog readers.

Now a reader has forwarded a reply that she got from Crystal Lake Joint Venture Partner Bob Irons:

“Thank you for contacting the Outback Steakhouse website.

My name is Bob Irons and I am the Joint Venture Partner for Outback in the Chicago area which includes the Crystal Lake, IL location.

I am aware of the media story about a waitress who was allegedly terminated for wearing a tea party bracelet.

Please be assured that this story is not true. We have not terminated a waitress for wearing a tea party bracelet.

To learn more about Outback, please visit our website www.outback.com - Company Info / Operation Feeding Freedom / Thanks for Giving.

Thank you again for your feedback.

Sincerely,

Bob Irons

Joint Venture Partner

= = = = =
After posting this, I found a video interview from the night of the protest. You can find it here on Breakdown of America.

This is the web site that posted the Crystal Lake Outback Steakhouse interview.

= = = = =
The following came as a comment from Outback Steakhouse below this article. I thought it deserved to be put in the article:

Thank you for your interest in Outback Steakhouse.

The employee was not let go because of her Tea Party bracelet. On the night in question two separate tables complained about her lack of attention – one flagging down the manager to pay their bill as they could not find her and another going to the bar because they received the wrong drink and could not find her.

Outback Steakhouse in Crystal Lake, Illinois

When the manager spoke to the employee about this she responded by yelling at him with a hostile attitude. This is why she was fired.She was not fired because a customer complained about her bracelet. That would have simply been handled by asking her to take off the bracelet.

As to the Illinois Department of Employment Security letter stating she was fired for wearing the bracelet – this simply reflects what the employee told them. No hearing was held that we participated in, nor did we submit any information regarding her claim.

I would also point out this bracelet is not a Marine Corps bracelet nor is it a bracelet supporting our troops. The bracelet has only the motto “Don’t Tread on Me” followed by “November 6, 2012”. November 6, 2012 is the next Presidential election. The bracelet does not have any Marine Corps insignia. When the customer asked the employee about the bracelet, she said it was a Tea Party bracelet.

You can find information on what our company does to honor our military and support our veterans on our website http://www.outback.com – click Company Info then click Operation Feeding Freedom and Thanks for Giving.

Thank you.

Joe Kadow
Outback Steakhouse

Walsh Opens Woodstock Office

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Demonstration, Joe Walsh, Office, Picket Sign, Woodstock

Next to the Woodstock Opera House is Stage Door Left. Directly across the Woodstock Square is Congressman Joe Walsh's new McHenry County Office.

Congressman Joe Walsh opened a Woodstock office right on the Square Monday morning.

Joe Walsh's new Woodstock office is in the Galleria. As you walk in, what direction do you think you have to turn? If you guessed, "Right," you were, well, right.

This is a government office, as opposed to the campaign office he opened in Downtown Crystal Lake the weekend before last.

Three men were on the sidewalk in front of Joe Walsh's office with homemade picket signs. I finally got them to stand so I could read all three. Here are the messages: "Vote No to Screaming Joe," "Let's Fire Joe Walsh," and "Joe Walsh is a national embarrassment."

As I approached the new digs, I saw people carrying picket signs.

White hair was all of her head that this woman holding a sign critical of Joe Walsh was willing to show. Her sign says, "Joe says I do not care about the loss of public sector jobs. Police...Firefighters...Teachers...Postal workers. Veterans say No to Joe." Of course, the only public workers on the woman's list who are paid by the Federal government are postal workers and email is decimating the purpose for which the Post Office was created.

Covering Joe Walsh, one always has photo opportunities.

But, phooey.  When I got inside, I discovered that my flash was jammed.

Rich and Monica Young chat at the Woodstock Joe Walsh office opening.


The Congressman was there, but the light was so poor and he moves so fast, I couldn’t get anything bu fuzzy photos.

Cost of Pavlin Case against the Sheriff’s Office to Taxpayers So Far

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Jerome Pavlin, Keith Nygren, McHenry County Sheriff, McHenry County Sheriff's Department

The warrantless search of Dr. Jerome Pavlin's home in unincorporated Crystal Lake criticized by Federal Judge Federick Kapala was conducted upstairs as well as downstairs, according to this Sheriff's Department photo.

Having published

  • an article about the case of the Dr. Jerome Pavlin, his wife and son against the McHenry County Sheriff’s Department, plus
  • a decision concerning summary judgment requests by Federal Judge Federick Kapala. (Through Saturday an amazing 109 people had read the decision.)

I thought you might like to know what it’s cost us taxpayers so far.

The named Sheriff’s Deputies in the suit were Jeremy Bruketa, Kyle Mandernack, Trevor Vogel, Christopher Jones, Ryan Lambert, Greg Pyle and David Shepherd.

The  suit charged

  • False Arrest,
  • Excessive Force,
  • Failure to Intervene,
  • Illegal Search of Home,
  • Civil Conspiracy and
  • Malicious Prosecution

You can see the allegations that didn’t meet the Court’s muster, plus those that merit a jury trial, plus the one count that the Judge already decided here and here.

The law firm of O’Halloran, Kosoff, Geitner & Cook was assigned to defend McHenry County and Sheriff Keith Nygren.

Just as in the case that former Deputy Sheriff Zane Siepler brought against the Sheriff and other members of his department for wrongful termination, the county has a “stop loss” clause in its insurance coverage.

In the cases of lawsuits handed off to a private attorney, county taxpayers are only on the hook for the first $100,000 of legal fees.

As in the Seipler case, where lawyer James Sotos has billed over $600,000. attorneys in the Pavlin case have racked up over $100.000 in legal fees.

McHenry County has racked up over $100,000 in legal fees on the case so, from one point of view, the case could be litigated to the U.S. Supreme Court without further cost to the taxpayers of McHenry County, except for time spent by deputies on the case during which they could be working elsewhere.

Take a look at the monthly billings that have submitted in the Pavlin case:

Ground Broken for Target Range in Crystal Lake

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Aaron Shepley, Bo Strom, Crystal Lake, Gary Reece, Ken Koehler, On Target, Shooting Range, Target Range

A press release from those building a shooting range in Crystal Lake:

On Target Breaks Ground in Crystal Lake

Range & Tactical Training Center Targeted to Open in March of 2012

CRYSTAL LAKE, IL – Area business leaders, elected officials, and local residents joined the founders of On Target Range & Tactical Training Center this morning to break ground in the Terra Cotta Tech Business Center in Crystal Lake. On a rainy Monday morning, the attendees found much to be excited about.

Bo Strom addresses the gathered dignitaries and the ground breaking.

“We’re so thankful for all the support we’ve received in McHenry County. So many people have already partnered up with us, from gun-rights groups and gun enthusiasts to public safety officials and firearm training organizations. We’re all eagerly anticipating the Grand Opening in March of 2012,” said Founding Partner Bo Strom of Charles River Group.

The earth movers are ready to begin their part of the construction work on the new shooting range in Crystal Lake.

Taking part in the groundbreaking, Crystal Lake Chamber of Commerce President Gary Reese lauded the business.

“We are always excited to see new businesses come into town. There is a lot of positive growth happening in Crystal Lake, and I want to thank you all for being part of the economic revitalization of our wonderful community.”

There were a number of other notable individuals in attendance, including McHenry County Board Chairman Ken Koehler.

What's a ground breaking without a ceremonial shovel?

Said Crystal Lake Mayor Aaron Shepley,

“In addition to the economic benefits this new business will bring to Crystal Lake, we’re also excited because of what it will do for our police department. Currently our officers have to travel to Winnebago County for their training, but when On Target opens they will be able to complete their training right here in town. That is invaluable.”

About On Target Range & Tactical Training Center:

On Target features a 20,500-square-foot indoor range offering a 12-position 75-foot Pistol Range and a 12-position 150-foot Rifle Range.

Also located within the facilities are

  • a large firearm and ammunition retail store,
  • a gunsmith shop, and
  • several classrooms featuring regular trainings and classes.

Hours of operation are anticipated to be 10am-8pm Monday-Saturday and 10am-7pm Sunday. For more information on On Target visit www.OnTargetSite.com or call (815) 477-2020.

Illinois Secretary of State – The Office that Keeps on Giving

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Driver's License, Illinois Secretary of State, Jesse White, Matthew Madden, Steven J. Dollear, Yasmin Best

The employees aren’t paid that much.

People really need drivers’ licenses.

Some people have a hard time getting one.

Is that a recipe for corruption or what?

Today the U.S. Attorney’s Office sent the following  press release about corruption in the Illinois Secretary of State’s Office.

No, it’s not like when Democrat Paul Powell and Republican George Ryan were in office.  No checks made out to Jesse White were found in his desk, as was the case with checks made out to Paul Powell when he died.

Here are the details:

STATE ROAD TEST EXAMINERS INDICTED FOR ALLEGEDLY ACCEPTING CASH BRIBES TO GUARANTEE PASSING TEST

CHICAGO — Two former road test examiners for the Illinois Secretary of State were indicted for allegedly accepting cash bribes to pass customers who were unqualified or never took the road test, federal law enforcement officials announced today.

The charges stem from an investigation that was unveiled in 2009 when members and associates of an alleged crime ring were accused of selling fraudulent identification documents in Chinatown on the city’s near south side.

The new defendants allegedly conspired between 2005 and 2007 with several of the defendants charged previously to accept cash bribes in return for guaranteeing that an unspecified number of customers would pass the road test, enabling them to obtain an Illinois driver’s license.

One defendant, Christopher Wardlaw, 36, was arrested today, while the other defendant, Alanda Jackson, 31, both of Chicago, will be ordered to appear for arraignment at a later date in U.S. District Court.

Both were road test examiners at the Secretary of State’s Chicago South Facility, located at 9901 South Dr. Martin Luther King Dr.

They were charged with one count of conspiracy to commit extortion in an indictment that was returned by a federal grand jury last Thursday and unsealed today following Wardlaw’s arrest.

Wardlaw was released on his own recognizance after appearing this morning before U.S. Magistrate Judge Jeffery T. Gilbert.

The indictment seeks forfeiture of $40,000, representing alleged illegal proceeds.

The charges were announced by Patrick J. Fitzgerald, United States Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois; Robert D. Grant, Special Agent-in-Charge of the Chicago Office of the FBI; Chicago Police Superintendent Garry F. McCarthy; and Illinois Secretary of State Inspector General James B. Burns.  The charges are part of Operation Paper Mountain, which has resulted in federal charges against approximately three dozen defendants since 2009.

According to the indictment, Wardlaw and Jackson conspired with another former SOS employee, Timothy Johnson, as well as with Jun Yun Zhang, Lili Liu, Tiansheng Zhang, and others, who were indicted in 2009.

Each of those defendants has pleaded guilty to related federal charges.

The Zhangs and other defendants routinely escorted customers to Secretary of State driver’s license facilities to fraudulently obtain state identification cards or driver’s licenses, typically using counterfeit or altered authentic Chinese passports and legitimate social security account numbers with the prefix “586” that were assigned to other people.  The 586 prefix is unusual because it is assigned to individuals in the Northern Mariana Islands, including Saipan, Guam and American Samoa.

When co-conspirators accompanied customers to the Chicago South facility, Wardlaw and Jackson allegedly guaranteed passing results on the road test either by serving as the examiner and passing  the customer even if he or she failed the road test, or by obtaining the customer’s road test paperwork from a co-conspirator and indicating that the customer passed when, in fact, the customer never took the test.

The government is being represented by Assistant U.S. Attorneys Matthew Madden, Steven J. Dollear and Yasmin Best.

Extortion conspiracy carries a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine.  If convicted, the Court must impose a reasonable sentence under federal statutes and the advisory United States Sentencing Guidelines

The public is reminded that an indictment contains only charges and is not evidence of guilt.  The defendants are presumed innocent and are entitled to a fair trial at which the government has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Tryon Recaps Veto Session

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Com Ed, ComEd, Commonwealth Edison, Property Tax, Property Tax Bill, Property Tax Cap, Property Tax Exemption, Property Tax Relief, Rate Hike, Regional Superintendent of Education, Regional Superintendent of Schools, Veto Override Session, Veto Session

Mike Tryon

An email from State Rep. Mike Tryon:

Our second week of veto session has ended, and while typically this would signify the end of the fall veto session, legislators are being called back to Springfield on Tuesday, November 29 to consider additional business. However, during the last few weeks several noteworthy votes have occurred.

House Bill 3793: Limits Property Tax Increases in Declining Housing Markets

Limiting property tax increases during times when housing values are declining is a discussion that needs to occur. The same tax cap laws that protected taxpayers in the years of unprecedented growth and prosperity in this area are now causing property taxes to increase while housing values are going down.

I am very sensitive to the issues faced by taxpayers in this declining economy and believe the taxing laws must be changed to protect taxpayers when their property values are decreasing.

As I have said many times, the economy is contracting and people are adjusting their budgets and getting by on less.

I believe the public sector needs to do the same.

This week I voted in favor of House Bill 3793.

The bill failed by a large margin.

The roll call on limiting tax districts from extracting more money during declining real estate markets.

The bill would have amended the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law (PTELL) to prevent any taxing body in a tax capped county from collecting an increase in funding during a year when the area’s total assessed value decreases.

There was fierce opposition to the bill by

  • school districts,
  • municipalities and
  • other agencies which rely on public funding for their operations.

I understand this opposition because property taxes are a primary funding source for these agencies, which provide important services that we all expect and rely upon.

At a time when the State is not making timely or full payments to them, the passage of House Bill 3793 would have created a significant hardship.

I have plans to file a bill which will require taxing bodies to publish in the newspaper the percentage increase of their tax rate as budgets are being finalized. I believe this new level of transparency would allow stakeholders to have additional information and an increased opportunity to be involved as taxing bodies’ budgets and levies and finalized.

Senate Bill 77: Unemployment Insurance Reform

It was with pleasure that I joined all other members of the House of Representatives in supporting Senate Bill 72, which reforms Illinois’ unemployment insurance system. Today the Unemployment Insurance Trust Fund has a projected deficit of $2.4 billion. This staggering sum threatens the very sustainability of this important safety net for working families. Through this bill, the fund will become fully solvent by 2018 and it will provide $400 million in cost savings for employers across the state. Most importantly, these reforms will be accomplished without raising taxes. The provisions of the bill should also help create private sector jobs and reinvigorate the Illinois economy.

Senate Bill 2147: Funding for Regional Offices of Education

Governor Quinn used his veto power several months ago to eliminate funding for Regional Offices of Education (ROEs) and their employees. Because of his veto, Regional Superintendents have not been paid since June. In fact, in McHenry County, the veto led to the current Regional Superintendent retiring early and the individual who had been elected to replace him declining the job. As a result, Lake County officials have been taking care of McHenry County’s ROE needs for the last five months.

I am a strong supporter of Regional Offices of Education and the statutory services they provide, and I voted in favor of restoring the funding for the remainder of this year from the personal property replacement taxes that are distributed to local governments each year. At the conclusion of this fiscal year funding for ROE’s will revert back to the General fund where I believe it belongs. The bill also creates a 15-member streamlining commission that will look for opportunities to consolidate some offices and duties. I favor the creation of this commission and look forward to learning about how we can increase efficiency and save money in these offices.

Senate Bill 1701: Emergency Medical Services Access

This bill amends the Illinois Controlled Substances Act and the Methamphetamine Control and Community Protection Act by providing that any person who, in good faith, dials 911 or seeks medical treatment for someone experiencing a drug overdose shall not be charged with a crime. I voted against this bill because I know that today in our area those who call in an expected overdose are usually not charged with a crime.

The bill creates a situation where drug dealers who administer a fatal dose of a tainted drug could escape prosecution. I believe strongly that drug dealers need to be prosecuted. The “common sense” approach currently used in our area appears to be working and I think we need to continue to look at each drug overdose case individually. However, the bill passed in the House and is now pending in the Illinois Senate.

Senate Bill 1652: Com Ed Smart Grid

Today, 44 states have some level of smart grid technology in place, and when Illinois lawmakers approved a bill several months ago to modernize Illinois’ grid, Governor Quinn vetoed it. During the first week of veto session, members of the House and Senate voted to override Governor Quinn’s veto. I voted in favor of the override and did so in part so that Illinois could become more competitive in attracting new businesses and jobs.

The original roll call on the bill that State Rep. Mike Tryon calls the "Smart Grid" bill.

The override means that once the improvements are in place, Illinoisans will have fewer and less widespread power outages than we have today. It will also provide the framework for Commonwealth Edison and Ameren to respond more quickly to network problems.

The fall veto override of the Com Ed bill Governor Pat Quinn vetoed.

The need to upgrade our electrical grid was never more obvious than earlier this year when many collar county residents were without power for extended periods of time due to storms. But Oak Park, which has been using the smart grid technology on an experimental basis since 2010, escaped the summer’s widespread storm outages while communities all around it suffered significant power outages. The Smart Grid improvements would not only help prevent widespread outages, but it would also provide for a wholesale technology upgrade that will eventually lower overall electrical costs.

A trailer bill presented the first week of veto session included language that lowers the profit rate for Commonwelath Edison and Ameren to rates that are lower than what the Illinois Commerce Commission (ICC) has allowed in the past.

The roll call on the Com Ed "trailer" bill.

The new language also toughens the performance standards they must meet and increases the amount of money they must spend to improve the infrastructure. The trailer bill also calls for the creation of a fund to help those of lower socioeconomic circumstances pay their electric bills. Based on the changes included in the trailer bill, a consortium of 42 suburbs withdrew its opposition to the bill prior to the override votes.

Gaming Expansion in Illinois

A new gaming bill that scaled back a gambling expansion package approved by the General Assembly several months ago was soundly defeated by the House last week. I voted against the gambling expansion bill when it was originally presented almost six months ago and I voted against the scaled back version last week. The new bill dropped a provision that would have allowed for slot machines at Chicago airports and the state fairgrounds, and addressed concerns by some that regulations were not stringent enough. However, the new plan still allowed for five new casinos in Illinois and permitted racetracks to operate slot machines.

I am not opposed to a modest expansion of gaming in our state such as the addition of slot machines at racetracks. The racing industry is a large part of the McHenry County economy. In my current legislative district, there are 13 thoroughbred farms and several other farms which supply crops and feed for the horses. My issue with the bill was the large nature of the expansion and the way in which the revenue would be spent. It is my hope that a new, scaled back version can be considered when we return to Springfield on November 29.

Coming Up… The Status of Pension Reform and, the Proposal to Close Seven State Facilities and the Sears EDA

Pension Reform…

There are a few other issues that may be debate and/or resolved when the General Assembly returns to Springfield on November 29. I am a member of the pension reform committee and we have met many times to discuss ways to stabilize the state’s pension system.

Today’s pension system includes an $86 billion unfunded liability. Those negotiations are ongoing and I look forward to reading Senate Bill 512 when it reaches its final form.

It is imperative that we solve the pension crisis, but we must do so in a manner that once and for all stabilizes the system without placing the $86 billion liability onto the backs of the taxpayers.

Facility Closures…

As you have probably heard, Governor Quinn recently recommended closing seven state facilities due to budget shortfalls. His announcement was premature, ill-thought out and included no plan for how the patients and inmates would be transitioned to new facilities.

It was nothing more than a political move on his part, and yet another attempt to press for additional funding by using some of Illinois’ most vulnerable citizens as pawns.

I also serve on the Commission on Government Forecasting and Accountability, and as a group we have been visiting these facilities and holding hearings over the last several weeks.

On Oct. 27 we voted against closing the Murphysboro juvenile detention center, Mabley Developmental Center in Dixon, Singer Mental Health Center in Rockford and Chester Mental Health Center.

Last week we voiced similar concerns by recommending against the closure of the Logan Correctional facility in Murphysboro, the Jacksonville Developmental Center and the Tinley Park Mental Hospital.

I am very much in favor of looking for opportunities to blend services so that efficiencies for providing services can be optimized. I also welcome an opportunity to review a comprehensive plan which includes a thorough cost-benefit analysis. To date, we have seen no plan and no cost-benefit analysis.

As the issue moves forward, I feel strongly that any ultimate changes would need to include a provision for a smooth transition for the individuals served by these facilitates.

Sears EDA…

Lastly, there has been much discussion and debate lately about Sears EDA in Hoffman Estates. As the 23-year tax incentive that brought Sears to Hoffman Estates approaches its 2013 expiration date, Sears is looking to the General Assembly to extend the terms of the EDA for an additional 15 years.

A huge property tax subsidy was passed over 23 years ago to help finance the move of Sears' corporate headquarters from the Sears Tower in Chicago's Loop to farmland next to the Northwest Tollway in Hoffman Estates. The legislator representing District 300, State Rep. Deloris Doederlein voted against the bill.

I am firmly opposed to the 15-year extension.

For the last 22 years, Sears has operated out of their space along I-90 between Beverly Road and Route 59 while enjoying significant property tax relief. I favor those original incentives and believe that at the time they were a necessary “carrot” that lured Sears and other businesses to the Hoffman Estates location. Jobs were created and the economic impact was very favorable.

District 300 officials have waited for the day when the EDA would expire so they could begin collecting the property tax revenue that rightfully belongs to them. Some legislators are trying to push through an incentive package that places the lion’s share of the sacrifice onto the backs of District 300 taxpayers. Simply put, it isn’t fair. It is my hope that my colleagues in the House and Senate slow down, take a step back, and create a piece of legislation that entices Sears to stay in Illinois while still being fair to the District 300 taxpayers.

I believe strongly that the next incentive package should be structured like the package we used to keep Motorola and its jobs in Illinois. The State gave Motorola a $100 million incentive package based on “EDGE” credits, whereby a percentage of the income taxes paid by Motorola employees was rebated back to the company. It was an incentive that was very lucrative for Motorola, and it wasn’t done at the expense of local taxpayers.

Clearly, all of Illinois is enriched by the economic activity that Sears brings to our state.

Therefore it is not equitable for the taxpayers of one school district to provide the overwhelming majority of the financial incentive that keeps Sears here. Since everyone benefits if Sears stays in Illinois, everyone should share in contributing toward making that happen.

As always, it is a pleasure to serve you in Springfield and at home. If I, or a member of my staff, may be of assistance to you in any way, please do not hesitate to contact my Crystal Lake office at (815) 459-6453 or at mike@miketryon.com.

Sincerely,

Michael W. Tryon
State Representative, District 64

Joseph’s Market Place Re-Opening Tuesday

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Crystal Lake Plaza, Joseph's Market

That’s what the new lighted sign at the Crystal Lake Plaza says.

Anyone want to be that Joseph's Market won't be packed when it re-opens Tuesday?

Jack Franks Hits a Taxeater Nerve

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Extension, Jack Franks, Leroy Eddy, Levy, Property Tax Bill, Property Tax Cap, Real Estate Assessments, Real Estate Tax, Real Estate Tax Bill, Tax Cap, Tax Eater, Taxeater

Daily SouthtownStar column by Phil Kadner about Jack Franks' bill to freeze the amount of real estate taxes that schools and other tax districts can get in a declining real estate marker.

It was the late 1960′s or early 1970′s when I heard or read State Rep. CL McCormick of Vienna coin the word “taxeater.”

I think it was when WBBM was running an evening Illinois House session live.

I admit to being enamored with what I heard. I’m sure it inspired me to run for state representative in 1972.

In any event, the word “taxeater” was so descriptive that it entered my vocabulary.

Even though it has applied to me most of my working life.

And still does, since I receive a generous legislative pension.

I wonder if you are ready to adopt the description of those supporters of tax hikes I first heard from St. Rep. CL McCormick (Paul Powell’s Republican colleague in the old 3-member districts)?

He called them “taxeaters.”

Of course, as a public pensioner and an ex-st rep., I was, too.

But “taxeater” or “taxeater’s friend” certainly fits our local government officials.

They successfully lobbyed Illinois House members to kill Franks’ House Bill 3793.  (34-73-5 vote roll call here.)

State Rep. Jack Franks’ bill to freeze property tax extensions has proven local tax district officials are
“taxeaters” without a shadow of a doubt.

And perhaps most of our state legislators began as local officials.

SouthtownStar columnist Phil Kadner doesn’t use the term “taxeater,” but his piece on Franks’ bill has lots of sparks.

How about a short course in what Franks has proposed.

The key is to the property tax system is the extension.

Not the assessment.

Not the tax rate.

What’s important is the amount of taxes the County Clerk tells the County Treasurer to collect.  (Your share of the total assessment tells your share of that total.)

I’ll bet no one can find one tax district whose levy for this coming year is not at least as much more than last year’s extension, plus the increase allowed by the Real Estate Tax Cap law, that is, last year’s extension, plus the CPI.

Inflationary increases allowed by the Tax Cap bill since the bill took effect. Click to enlarge.

The inflationary increase allowed this year is 1.5%.

There will be a very, very short list of local governments who don’t grab for everything they can get.

Because real estate inflation greatly exceeded the increase in the CPI over the years since the Tax Cap took effect, tax rates were forced down.

(Remember all the self-laudatory press releases about how this district or that district lowered its tax rate? Meaningless, of course, since the taxes extended were what really mattered, and they kept going up, but a lot of reporters accepted the claims as being newsworthy.)

That means most, if not all, non-Home Rule tax districts have rates below their statutory minimum.

And, that, in turn, means when a tax district asks for last year’s tax extension (that is, pretty much the amount it received), plus the CPI increase allowed by PTELL (the name the technocrats give the Property Tax Cap), the County Clerk will just raise its rates to give the school or other tax district the extra money requested.

It matters not at all that assessments have decreased.

A bit complicated, but freezing the extension was what Jack’s bill was all about.

And, he has the right target.

The ignorant in the General Assembly claimed that the change would impede tax growth when the market turns around.

That is nonsense, of course.

When the real estate prices start climbing, taxes will be allowed to increase by as much as the Consumer Price Index goes up.

Related to this discussion is my advice to McHenry County Board members.  The Board seems poised to hike its taxes next year to the maximum amount allowed by law.

This article is about what Board members (and any other tax district officials who are really on the taxpayers’ side) could do to keep taxes pretty much constant:

No Financial Diet for McHenry County Next Year + The Tax Levy Game

Those that don’t deserve to be called “taxeaters” because their demonstrated goal will have been show to maximum the amount of money that can be extracted from homeowners’ pockets.

They are following the advice of Louis XIV’s Exchequer:

“The art of taxation is like plucking a goose: to get the most feathers with the least amount of hissing.”

Not the original “taxeater,” but certainly a role model.

= = = = =

Some have suggested that Franks was just searching for headlines by promoting the bill.  I lean in that direction.

A lot of his colleagues apparently believe the same thing.  Consider this from the Daily Herald story on the bill’s defeat:

“Franks was ribbed by other lawmakers who accused him of grandstanding over the issue.

“’It was almost like a press conference you were holding,’ said Rep. Roger Eddy, a Republican from downstate Hutsonville.”

State Rep. Roger Eddy is a double-dipping taxeater. Not only is he a state representative. In his day job, he is a school superintendent.

Tuesday Occupy Wall Street Support Group Demonstration in Woodstock

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: 99% of McHenry County, Occupy Wall Street, Woodstock

A press release from “99% of McHenry County:”

Rally by the 99% in Support of the Occupy Movement Set for Tuesday

 

The demonstration will be held at the Unitarian Universalist Church in Woodstock.

Woodstock—A Rally by the 99% of McHenry County in support of the Occupy Movement will be held on Tuesday, November 15 from 5 to 6:30 PM in front of the Unitarian Universalist Congregation of Woodstock at the corner of Dean and South Streets.  The rally is sponsored by the church’s Social Justice Committee

The Rally will also collect supplies urgently needed by Occupy Chicago as it moves into the winter months.
“We have been very encouraged by the response we have had from the community,” said Patrick Murfin, coordinator of the event for the Committee.
Unitarian Universalist congregations around the country and related organizations like the Unitarian Universalist Service Committee and the Standing on the Side of Love campaign have been supportive of the spreading movement inspired by Occupy Chicago.
The event is open to all members of the 99% who support the movement.
“Participants are invited to make a sign telling how they are members of the 99%—the  great majority of Americans who have been  left behind as the top 1% amasses unheard of wealth,” Murfin said.
Participants are also asked to bring supplies for Occupy Chicago.  Among the items needed are warm winter clothing, mittens and gloves, wool socks, caps, scarves, sleeping bags, blankets, and non perishable food items.  A complete list of items needed is available upon request.
“We ask donors to only bring items to the Church during the rally and not at other times,” Murfin said.  “If someone has a donation but can’t attend the rally, they can contact me and I will try to arrange a pick-up.
For further information e-mail Patrick Murfin at pmurfin@sbcglobal.net or call 815-814-5645.

Point, Counter Point – Sotos, Horwitz Both Request Sanctions – Part 5

November 14, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Blake Horwitz, CD, Elizabeth Barton, James Sotos, John Miller, Kathleen Seith, Keith Nygren, McHenry County Sheriff, McHenry County Sheriff's Department, Michael Mahoney, Video, William Lutz, Zane Seipler

Besides violating the confidentiality court order in former Sheriff’s Deputy Zane Seipler’s wrongful termination case, his attorney Blake Horwitz argues in his motion for sanctions that defendant McHenry County Sheriff’s lawyer James Sotos has wrongfully withheld a long video interview made of Seipler by the Department.

As before, paragraphing and formatting has been added in the text to make the text easier to read on a computer screen.

“The Video Recording

“This Court recently granted Plaintiff leave to re-take the deposition of two Defendants, Lutz and Miller, given Defendants’ failures in producing a lengthy video taken of the Plaintiff during the Plaintiff’s internal investigation into racial profiling and ticket writing. See Order, Dkt No. 311, October 12, 2011.

“Plaintiff desires to remind the Court that three affidavits were filed in support of the Defendants’ position that the video was somehow lost. (Exhibit J, Affidavits of Defendants Miller and Lutz and Affidavit of Elizabeth Barton). These affidavits were filed by party defendants and their counsel (Ms. Barton) in response to Plaintiffs motion to compel and this Court’s order (Dkt No. 134) [Foot Note 3].

James Sotos

“This Court will recall Mr. Sotos’ recent oral argument before the Court, where he stated that the hour long video was recently ‘found’, but only after the Plaintiff’s deposition was taken.

“During Mr. Sotos’ argument, this Court on repeatedly referenced the ‘convenient’ post-deposition find and then granted Plaintiff’s motion to compel as to the two Defendants.

“Notably, Defendant Affiant Seith stated that she gave the CD to the Sotos law firm (Exhibit J, pg 5, para 6) but then the video became ‘missing’ (Id. para. 8).

“Ms. Barton, a Sotos Associates states that she performed a ‘reasonably search’, including Mr. Sotos’ involvement, to obtain the video (Exhibit J, para 5 and 7).

“Apparently, the search became more reasonable after the Plaintiff testified.”

= = = = =

Foot Note 3 – “As to Plaintiff’s motion to compel the production of an audio-video recording of the internal investigation of Plaintiff, Defendants are ordered to complete a reasonable search to produce the compact disc. According to the Defendants’ affidavit, a copy of the disc was sent to Heidi Parker, but no explanations have been proffered as to efforts to locate this copy, or any other copies that may exist. Within 21 days, Defendants shall either produce a copy of the compact disc, or submit an affidavit to the court to explain why Ms. Parker’s copy is unavailable.”

= = = = =

In addition to asking for sanctions, Seipler attorney Horwitz asks for “attorneys’ fees for having prevailed with regard to depositions of Miller and Lutz (concerning the newly found video).”

= = = = =

More tomorrow.

= = = = =
Other articles in the series: