McHenry County Blog

Subscribe

Archive for the ‘Frangible’

Sheriff’s Deputy Injured on Firing Range Sues Frangible Ammunition Firm

December 06, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Bullet, Bulllet Wound, Eric Woods, Frangible, Frangible Ammunition, Gun, Injury, International Cartridge Corporation, McHenry County Sheriff, McHenry County Sheriff's Department, Shooting, Shooting Range

The firm that provided the ammunition that is supposed to disintegrate upon impact was sued by McHenry County Sheriff’s Deputy Eric Woods in Federal Court on January 25, 2011.

McHenry County Blog obtained the purchase orders through a Freedom of Information Act request and published an article on April 30, 2010.

International Cartridge Corporation of Reynoldsville, Pennsylvania was the supplier.

In his suit, being represented by Rockford attorney Kevin P. Justen, Woods asks for more that $75,000, apparently a needed threshold for gaining Federal jurisdiction, for what happened on the McHenry County Sheriff’s Department’s Shooting Range on March 15th.

The brief points out that ICC’s bullet “fragments of the frangible bullet rebounded and ricocheted into” Woods as a result of a “manufacturing defect…the  bullets did not disintegrate on impact.”

There was not adequate warning of this “hazard,” the suit says.

An International Cartridge Corporation video promotes no ricocheting. More visuals at the original article linked above.

The “defects that rendered the frangible bullets unreasonably dangerous to its intended users were the proximate cause of the personal injuries and damages sustained by” Woods.

And what was he impact of the injury on Woods?

“Woods

  • sustained severe and permanent bodily injuries,
  • resulting in the Plaintiff incurring medical bills and expenses in endeavoring to treat and cure his injuries,
  • has caused him great pain and suffering, and will cause him in the future great pain and suffering, and
  • he has lost great gains that would have otherwise been made and acquired and will in the future lose gains he would have made and acquired and he has and continues to be impaired from going about his daily affairs,

all to his damage.”

The nature of the injuries are described as

  • personal,
  • pecuniary and
  • permanent

You can read the original filing here.

Shooting Range Ammo Used Day Eric Woods Got Wounded

April 30, 2010 By: Cal Skinner Category: Bullet, Bulllet Wound, Eric Woods, Frangible, Frangible Ammunition, International Cartridge Corporation, Keith Nygren, McHenry County, McHenry County Sheriff, McHenry County Sheriff's Department, Shooting Range, Target

Still trying to discover the details of what happened March 15th when McHenry County Sheriff’s Deputy is reported to have been shot by ricocheting frangible ammunition, I filed a Freedom of Information request asking for its purchase order.

Here’s what I asked for:

“Under the Freedom of Information Act, I request purchase order(s) for the frangible ammunition used on March 15 at the Shooting Range during the SWAT Team training during which Eric Woods was injured.”

Freedom of Information Officer Jan Weech sent the following:

“The document attached is a copy of a quote we received for the Ammunition that we ordered and received.  This Ammunition was the supply that was used at our Range on the date that you requested.”

Take a look at what was purchased from International Cartridge Corporation, based in Reynoldsville,
PA.:

I’ve copied the “Quotation” document in three parts.  Click on any image and it will enlarge enough for you to be able to read it.

The firm has a web site. You see the top below:

The top of the front page of International Cartridge Corporation's web site.

The second paragraph of the introduction, most of which you can see at the bottom of the screen above, says,

“Conventional ammunition has a significant hazard associated with close range fire, ricochet and over penetration. The International Cartridge Corporation’s round has controlled fragmentation characteristics while maintaining lethal penetrating capabilities. This unique performance reduces hazard for the shooter without compromising firepower.” (Emphasis added.]

There are videos. Here’s a ten-second one entitled “Highspeed Video” that shows what happens to a frangible bullet when it hits something. It breaks apart.

Frangible bullet at eight second mark in the short video.

There’s a longer one which shows the dust left after frangible bullets are shot.

A man pours dust created after frangible ammunition shot into a four-sided target area from one hand to another. It reminds me of the sand in an hour glass.

The video shows a man hammering a bullet. It turns to dust.

Dust remains on the surface after this frangible bullet was hit by a hammer.

It promotes the lack of fragmentation.

An opening title in the longer (about six minute) video entitled introduction.

And the lack of ricocheting.  Actually, the description of the ammunition is “NO RICOCHET.”

The video promotes no ricocheting.

“Standard jacketed ammunition will ricochet and has inherent danger (pictured to the right). Due to the characteristics of ICC frangible ammunition, hazards are reduced and in most situations, eliminated completely.”

"Offering Controlled Fragmentiion" is the title under this section of the video.

There’s a pledge of “Reduced Hazard.”

"Reduced Hazard" is the message under this section of the longer video.

I can't tell whether this man is wearing a protective vest or not as he approaches the target. Note the smaller steel targte resembles the one on the McHenry County shooting range from which bullets are said to have ricocheted into Eric Woods leg, hand, arm and face.

There is no lead in these frangible bullets.

If this frangible ammunition were being used, there should have been no lead fragments removed from Eric Woods at the Woodstock hospital or during the next hospital visit in McHenry.

Training is simulated in a shooting range with steel targets.

Steel plate SWAT training is shown.

And, there’s a section which shows men entering a room for SWAT team practice.

Two men enter the room in one demonstration. See part starting at 4 minutes and fifty seconds into the long video.

The first man to enter engages the closet target, which just happens to be  low, similar, even though a bit higher,  to what those at the McHenry County shooting range described after Deputy Eric Woods was injured by ricocheting bullet fragments.

The first man in the room shoots at the closet target. It is relatively low, on top of a steel drum, and can be seen to the right in this frame of the long video.

The first man in the room hits the low target on the barrel.

After hitting the target on the barrel, these men advance farther into the shooting range. The second man aims at the second target sighted.

Just thought you might be interested.