November 24, 2012
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Education Fund, Fox River Grove Grade School District 3, Harrison Grade School District 36, Harvard School District 50, Tax Cap, Tax Rate, Wonder Lake

West Elementary School in Crystal Lake.
Looking at maximum tax rates for school districts in McHenry County, I discovered that Fox River Grove Elementary School District 3 is blocked from raising its taxes not by the Property Tax Cap, but by having reached it $3.50 per $100 value statutory tax rate limit.
The Board asked for $4.3 million, but was allowed a bit over $4 million due to having reached the tax rate allowed by law.
The grade school district on the east side of Wonder Lake has the same situation.
Harrison Elementary School District 36′s Education Fund is at its $3.50 per $100 of assessed valuation maximum.
Of the other districts, Harvard Unit District is due to bump up against its $4 per $100 of AV maximum Education Fund rate next year.
If Harvard could get the extra 3% allowed by the tax cap, its rate would be $4.03.
And all school districts near their statutory tax rate limits have to worry about the projected 9% decrease in assessment base.
But, because of the maximum rate governing is Education Fund it will be able to increase its Education Fund by about 2.3%.
Districts like the the following have not reached their maximum Education Fund tax limit:
- Cary Grade School
- Crystal Lake Grade School
- Marengo-Union Grade School
- Richmond-Spring Grove (Nippersink) Grade School
- McHenry Grade School
- Prairie Grove Grade School
- Riley Grade School
- Crystal Lake High School
- Marengo High School
- McHenry High School
- Richmond-Burton High School
- Alden-Hebron Unit District
- Barrington Unit District
- Belvidere Unit District
- Carpentersville Unit District
- Huntley Unit District
- Johnsburg Unit District
- Wauconda Unit District
- Woodstock Unit District
Comments (2)
July 07, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Alden-Hebron School District 19, Alden-Hebron Unit District 19, Cary-Grove High School, Crystal Lake Central High School, Crystal Lake High School District 155, Crystal Lake South High School, English, Harvard High School, Harvard School District 50, Huntley High School, Huntley School District 158, Marengo High School, Marengo High School District 156, McHenry County College, McHenry East High School, McHenry High School District 156, Remedial, Richmond-Bruton High School, Woodstock High School, Woodstock North High School, Woodstock School District 200
Yesterday, McHenry County Blog published the percentage of incoming freshmen at McHenry County College require remedial math classes.
The best high school district was Huntley’s at 46% needing help to be able to take a college course.
Today, we look at the situation with regard to English.
It’s much better.
The average is only 11%.
So, take a look at the figures for each of the high school districts in McHenry County College District 528:
Previously, I typed out the results math results so people could find them with an internet search engine. Today, we’ll do the same for preparation for college English, except going from best to worst.
- Alden-Hebron – 0%
- Richmond-Burton – 6%
- Marengo – 8%
- Johnsburg – 9%
- McHenry – 11%
- Crystal Lake, Cary-Grove – 11%
- Woodstock – 14%
- Huntley – 20%
- Harvard – 38%
Again, explanations are welcomed in the comment section.
Comments (8)
June 03, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Crystal Lake High School District 155, District 300, Gene Hoffman, Harvard School District 50, High School, Huntley School District 158, Johnsburg School District, Marengo High School District 156, Marengo School District, McHenry County, McHenry High School District 156, Richmond Burton High School District 157, Teacher, Teacher Pay, Teacher Salaries, Woodstock Unit School District 200
The Chicago Sun-Times released a school teacher and administrator data base this week that some might find interesting.
“Salary data includes base, summer-, after-school pay, benefits, vacation- or sick-day payouts, pre-retirement salary bumps. Average includes only full-time employees,” says the print on top of the search engine page.
Not specifically mention, but included is the pension payments that taxpayers pay for teachers and administrators. Teachers are supposed to pay 9.4%, but many in McHenry County and elsewhere don’t. Those who must pay the employee share of Social Security might be envious of this negotiated deal.
First I looked for average salaries for high school teachers in McHenry County’s districts. You see the results below:

Average compensation for McHenry County's High School District's teachers.

District 300 is classified by state policy-makers as a Kane County school district, so it cannot be combined with the other districts in McHenry County.
You might find it of interest to compare the salaries with the percentage of students who meet or exceed state standards.
Those high schools where students do the best are Crystal Lake and Richmond-Burton.
67.9% for Richmond-Burton High School District and 67.3% for District 155. Both have a similar percentage of low income kids. Richmond-Burton’s is a tad higher than Crystal Lake’s.
Compare the average compensation of Crystal Lake and Richmond-Burton and there is no contest.
Crystal Lake High School District 155 ranks 16th highest in the state with average compensation of $91,960. $62,237 is Richmond-Burton’s average, almost $30,000 less.
District 155 is currently in secret negotiations with its IEA teachers’ union.
Even a cursory review of the salary data will show that teaching in a high school district is the way to make the most money.
As I have explained before, the legislator who wrote the Resource Equalizer State Aid to Education formula in the mid-1970′s was a high school teachers from a high school district.
State Rep. Gene Hoffman figured out how to make sure high school districts benefited most for the formula. From the figures above, you’d have to agree he achieved his goal.
It doesn’t always work out as well as it does for Crystal Lake’s District 155 teachers. Marengo and Richmond-Burton are also high school districts. The others are unit district, meaning all 13 grades are governing by one school board.
I am sure some commentators will want to share their analyses of these statistics.
Not having figured out how to make charts, but wanting people to be able to search the data, I present below the raw data. Get the headings from the image above.
| 16 |
CHSD 155 |
McHenry |
$91,959.72 |
11.86 |
7.8 |
67.4 |
High School Teacher |
| 74 |
McHenry CHSD 156 |
McHenry |
$68,392.57 |
9.7 |
10.5 |
58.3 |
High School Teacher |
| 96 |
Marengo CHSD 154 |
McHenry |
$65,754.02 |
11.78 |
18.4 |
60.9 |
High School Teacher |
| 110 |
Johnsburg CUSD 12 |
McHenry |
$63,468.73 |
12.55 |
14.2 |
61.7 |
High School Teacher |
| 115 |
Woodstock CUSD 200 |
McHenry |
$62,614.35 |
11.42 |
27.8 |
58.9 |
High School Teacher |
| 120 |
Richmond-Burton CHSD 157 |
McHenry |
$62,236.80 |
9.89 |
9.7 |
67.9 |
High School Teacher |
| 239 |
Cons SD 158 |
McHenry |
$53,288.16 |
7.35 |
9.9 |
63.1 |
High School Teacher |
| 254 |
Harvard CUSD 50 |
McHenry |
$52,338.04 |
9.62 |
49.7 |
41.3 |
High School Teacher |
| 331 |
Alden Hebron SD 19 |
McHenry |
$48,584.08 |
11.77 |
18.3 |
58.1 |
High School Teacher |
Comments (2)
May 16, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Alton, Argo, Arlington Heights, Aurora, Ball Chatham, Belleville, Belvidere School District, Berwyn, Bremen Township, Cahokia, Canton, Cary Elementary School District 26, Cary Grade School District, Champaign, Chicago Public Schools, Chicago Schools, Cicero, Collinsville, Crete-Monee, Crystal Lake Grade School District 47, Crystal Lake High School District 155, Danville, Decatur, DeKalb, District 155, District 165, District 2, District 200, District 26, District 3, District 300, District 47, Dixon, Dolton, Downers Grove, East Maine, Edwardsville, Effingham, Elgin School District, Elmhurst, Evanston, Freeport, Geneva, Genoa, Grayslake Unit School District 46, Harvard School District 50, Harvey, Highland Park, Homewood, Illinois Education Association, Illinois State Board of Education, Johnsburg School District, Joliet, Kaneland School District 302, Kankakee, Kevin McCarthy, Larry Snow, LaSalle, Lemont, Leyden Township, Lockport Township, Lombard, Lyons Township, Manteno, Marion, Massac, Mattoon, McHenry Grade School District 15, McHenry High School District 156, Moline, Naperville Unit District 203, New Lenox, Niles, Nippersink Elementary School District 2, North Boone, O'Fallon, Oak Lawn, Palatine, Park Ridge, Pension, Peoria, Peru, Plainfield, Proviso Township, Quincy, Reed Custer, Rochester, Rockford School District, Round Lake School District 116, Schaumburg, Schiller Park, School, Springfield, St. Charles School District, Summit Hill, Sycamore School District 427, Taylorville, Teacher Negotiations, Teacher Pay, Teacher Pension, Teacher Salaries, Teachers Retirement System, Teachers Union, Thornton Township, Tolono, Union, Urbana, Valley View, Warren Township High School District, Wauconda, Waukegan, West Chicago, Wheeling, Wilmington, Woodstock School District 200, Yorkville, Zion

Larry Snow
“While Democrats say Teachers ‘Have Kept Their Part of the Deal?’“
is the title of an April 5, 2011, article by former Huntley School District 158 Board member Larry Snow. (The quote was in the Chicago Tribune Marcy 31, 2011. It is from Executive Director Dick Ingram of Teachers’ Retirement System.)
The article was published in “The Champion” with this teaser:
“82,981 of 132,502 Illinois Teachers Pay Nothing or Little into Their Pensions“
That’s 63% of all teachers in Illinois.
The State Journal-Register is reporting that State Rep. Kevin McCarthy (D-Orland Park) is promoting a bill where state and local governments would all pay six percent of payroll toward employee pensions.
In a revealing sentence in reporter Chris Wetterich’s article, he writes,
“What’s unclear is how much more employees themselves would have to pay.“
Because no one has done the research except, I believe, the Illinois Education Association and Snow, how much extra teachers would have to pay if their so-called contribution rate was raised from 9.4% to 13.77% is a really good question.
While not covering every school district in Illinois, Snow did research the teachers’ contracts for all of the large school districts (by law all are supposed to be on the internet) in order to find out how much teachers pay in order to get a “full 75 percent pension after working only 27 years.” He points out, “Most adults work for 27 years before they turn age 50.”
As way of background, Snow notes that teachers are not in the Social Security System and, therefore, are not forced to pay Social Security taxes.
“Ordinary workers get hit with a 6.2 percent deduction for Social Security,” Snow writes. “It’s a deduction they have to pay federal and state income taxes on.
“Democrats gave teachers a huge loophole of not paying income taxes on any of their pension deductions” he continues. “This enormous no-tax handout to teachers amounts to billions of dollars each year.”
Snow’s research leads him to this conclusion:
“Over 51,000 of the total 132,502 teachers in Illinois contribute nothing from their K-12 paychecks into their pensions. Illinois law says it is to be 9.4 percent.
“About an additional 32,000 teachers pay little into their pensions. It is 1.81 percent to be precise for these 31,956 teachers.“
How many teachers pay not a dime toward their retirement?
51,025 teachers in 186 school districts pay nothing for retirement benefits.
They “don’t pay a penny into the 9.4 percent called out by Illinois law.
“There are a total of 868 districts in Illinois.
“The pay-zero teachers listed are 39 percent of all teachers in Illinois,” Snow reveals.
No agency in state government seems to keep track of this information.
Not the Downstate Teachers Retirement Fund, which boldly and incorrectly claims,
“Active TRS members are required to contribute 9.4 percent of their creditable earnings each year…”
The State Board of Education doesn’t keep track either.
My guess is that only the Illinois Education Association has a matrix showing what school districts have given what benefits in contract negotiations.
Snow discovered this about Lockport:
“…on page 14 of the Lockport Township HS 205 teachers contract it reads:
- The Board will pay the current level of retirement contribution to the Teachers Retirement System of Illinois.”
- It is expressly understood that figures appearing on this salary schedule include a sum equal to the current level of TRS contribution of the base salary of each Teacher which is, in fact, payable to the Teachers’ Retirement System on the Teacher’s behalf.”
“The ISBE report shows this board paying nothing. A Democrat bureaucracy doesn’t check the teachers contracts to see if what is reported, matches what’s in writing.”
And, if legislation is passed requiring 4.37 percentage points more, how long do you think it will take Lockport taxpayers to pick up the difference?
Given that local teachers’ unions pretty much control school boards wherever they are elected (read everywhere but Chicago), my guess is will be on the top of the collective bargaining list.
Do you wonder if Rep. McCarthy knows that?
Is his proposal just a setting up local taxpayers for an even bigger fall?
Five years from now will 39% of teachers still be paying nothing for their pensions?
Even better for teachers is that this pension payment ups their pension payments.
Take a look at the chart below. Chances are your school district is on it.
Chart of Pension Contributions by 82,981 District Teachers of 132,502 Total Illinois K-12 Teachers
-
| Name of District
|
No. of Teachers |
Percent of Pension
Contributed by Teachers |
| Thornton Twp 205 |
428 |
Zero |
| Proviso 209 |
281 |
Zero |
| Waukegan 60 |
1,098 |
Zero |
| Morton 201 |
455 |
Zero |
| Kankakee 111 |
348 |
Zero |
| Joliet 204 |
340 |
Zero |
| Round Lake 116 |
387 |
Zero |
| Rockford |
1,843 |
Zero |
| Decatur 61 |
454 |
Zero |
| Crete Monee |
340 |
Zero |
| Danville 118 |
382 |
Zero |
| Valley View 365 |
1,068 |
Zero |
| Aurora West 129 |
706 |
Zero |
| East Peoria 309 |
69 |
Zero |
| Galesburg |
281 |
Zero |
| Bremen 228 |
313 |
Zero |
| Freeport |
317 |
Zero |
| Leyden 212 |
219 |
Zero |
| Elgin U-46 |
2,332 |
Zero |
| Rock Island |
388 |
Zero |
| Mattoon |
225 |
Zero |
| Collinsville |
394 |
Zero |
| Massac 1 |
143 |
Zero |
| Sterling |
219 |
Zero |
| Belvidere |
531 |
Zero |
| Quincy |
436 |
Zero |
| Dixon |
179 |
Zero |
| West Chicago |
248 |
Zero |
| Cook County 130 |
289 |
Zero |
| Cicero 99 |
738 |
Zero |
| Joliet 86 |
617 |
Zero |
| Harvey 152 |
163 |
Zero |
| Crystal Lake 155 |
412 |
Zero |
| Crystal Lake 47 |
564 |
Zero |
| Wheeling 21 |
489 |
Zero |
| Champaign 4 |
717 |
Zero |
| United CUSD 304 |
68 |
Zero |
| Riverdale 100 |
76 |
Zero |
| Reed Custer 255 |
114 |
Zero |
| Wilmington 209U |
84 |
Zero |
| United Township 30 |
90 |
Zero |
| Summit Hill 161 |
213 |
Zero |
| Plainfield |
1,695 |
Zero |
| Schiller Park 81 |
98 |
Zero |
| Dolton 149 |
176 |
Zero |
| Township 211 Palatine |
799 |
Zero |
| Ball Chatham 5 |
248 |
Zero |
| Taylorville 3 |
152 |
Zero |
| Williamsville 15 |
81 |
Zero |
| Harrisburg 3 |
130 |
Zero |
| Belleville 201 |
281 |
Zero |
| Dupo 196 |
76 |
Zero |
| O’Fallon 203 |
145 |
Zero |
| O’Fallon 90 |
207 |
Zero |
| Rochester 3A |
142 |
Zero |
| Pekin 108 |
248 |
Zero |
| Morton 709 |
175 |
Zero |
| New Lenox 122 |
287 |
Zero |
| Frankfort 157 |
158 |
Zero |
| Marion 2 |
219 |
Zero |
| Carterville 5 |
110 |
Zero |
| Kinnikinnick 131 |
122 |
Zero |
| Tolono 7 |
116 |
Zero |
| Mahomet-Seymour 3 |
161 |
Zero |
| Champaign 4 |
717 |
Zero |
| Urbana |
346 |
Zero |
| Charleston 1 |
180 |
Zero |
| Park Ridge 64 |
319 |
Zero |
| Evanston 202 |
222 |
Zero |
| Maine HSD 207 |
508 |
Zero |
| Arlington Heights 214 |
753 |
Zero |
| Niles 219 |
350 |
Zero |
| Berkeley 87 |
165 |
Zero |
| Berwyn South |
263 |
Zero |
| Lyons 204 |
239 |
Zero |
| Lemont 113 |
144 |
Zero |
| Palatine 15 |
713 |
Zero |
| Schaumburg 54 |
1,003 |
Zero |
| Oak Lawn 123 |
203 |
Zero |
| Oak Lawn 229 |
114 |
Zero |
| CHSD 230 Orland Park |
519 |
Zero |
| Argo 217 |
111 |
Zero |
| Homewood 233 |
174 |
Zero |
| Genoa 424 |
137 |
Zero |
| Sycamore 427 |
231 |
Zero |
| Dekalb 428 |
362 |
Zero |
| Lombard 44 |
216 |
Zero |
| Downers Grove 58 |
277 |
Zero |
| Hinsdale 86 |
296 |
Zero |
| Elmhurst 205 |
538 |
Zero |
| Naperville 203 |
1,063 |
Zero |
| Effingham 40 |
176 |
Zero |
| Canton Union 66 |
175 |
Zero |
| Morris 54 |
61 |
Zero |
| Morris 101 |
50 |
Zero |
| Coal City 1 |
138 |
Zero |
| Jersey 100 |
164 |
Zero |
| Central CUSD 301 |
224 |
Zero |
| Kaneland 302 |
275 |
Zero |
| St. Charles 303 |
880 |
Zero |
| Cahokia |
298 |
0.4 |
| Chicago Public Schools |
23,219 |
2 |
| Peoria 150 |
988 |
0.4 |
| Springfield |
1,105 |
0.4 |
| Moline 40 |
461 |
0.4 |
| Harvard |
149 |
0.87 |
| Dolton 148 |
236 |
1.4 |
| Belleville 118 |
228 |
0.4 |
| Pekin 303 |
125 |
0.4 |
| Hononegah 207 |
118 |
0.4 |
| Arlington Heights 59 |
444 |
3 |
| Leyden 212 |
219 |
0.4 |
| Summit 104 |
103 |
0.4 |
| Palos 118 |
130 |
0.4 |
| CHSD 219 Orland Park |
519 |
0.4 |
| Bensenville 2 |
145 |
1.4 |
| DuPage 88 |
266 |
0.4 |
| CHSD 94 |
122 |
0.9 |
| CUSD 300 |
1,189 |
4.4 |
| Hawthorn 73 |
253 |
1.4 |
| Lake Forest 115 |
132 |
0.4 |
| Wauconda 118 |
273 |
0.4 |
| Johnsburg 12 |
158 |
0.4 |
| Cary 26 |
192 |
4.9 |
| Woodstock 200 |
385 |
1.4 |
| Keeneyville 20 |
107 |
0.4 |
| Winnebago 323 |
117 |
0.4 |
| LaSalle-Peru Twp. 120 |
88 |
0.7 |
| Prairie-Hills 144 |
187 |
0.4 |
| Geneva 304 |
367 |
Zero |
| Herscher 2 |
126 |
Zero |
| Manteno 5 |
160 |
Zero |
| Bourbonnais 53 |
160 |
Zero |
| Bradley 61 |
103 |
Zero |
| Bradley Bourbonnais 307 |
114 |
Zero |
| Momence 1 |
88 |
Zero |
| Yorkville 115 |
329 |
Zero |
| Plano 88 |
154 |
Zero |
| Oswego 308 |
827 |
Zero |
| Streator 44 |
132 |
Zero |
| Ottawa 141 |
140 |
Zero |
| Ottawa 140 |
102 |
Zero |
| Glenview 34 |
343 |
Zero |
| Zion 6 |
177 |
Zero |
| Grayslake 46 |
266 |
Zero |
| Elmwood Park 401 |
181 |
Zero |
| Libertyville 70 |
159 |
Zero |
| North Shore 112 |
374 |
Zero |
| HSD 113 Highland Park |
249 |
Zero |
| Grant 124 |
91 |
Zero |
| Zion-Benton 126 |
156 |
Zero |
| Evanston 65 |
547 |
Zero |
| Grayslake 127 |
187 |
Zero |
| Meridian 15 |
64 |
Zero |
| Mt. Zion 3 |
133 |
Zero |
| Edwardsville 7 |
480 |
Zero |
| Alton 11 |
467 |
Zero |
| Macomb 185 |
130 |
Zero |
| McHenry 15 |
282 |
Zero |
| McHenry 156 |
158 |
Zero |
| Nippersink 2 |
92 |
Zero |
| Columbia 4 |
111 |
Zero |
| Waterloo 5 |
166 |
Zero |
| Hillsboro 3 |
114 |
Zero |
| Meridian 223 |
113 |
Zero |
| Illinois Valley Central 321 |
139 |
Zero |
| Carbondale 165 |
76 |
Zero |
| Carbondale 95 |
105 |
Zero |
| Riverton 14 |
85 |
Zero |
| Auburn 10 |
90 |
Zero |
| Pawnee 11 |
47 |
Zero |
| Panhandle 2 |
35 |
Zero |
| Sullivan 300 |
75 |
Zero |
| Centralia 135 |
93 |
Zero |
| Litchfield 12 |
83 |
Zero |
| Harlem 122 |
505 |
Zero |
| Granite City 9 |
617 |
Zero |
| Princeton 115 |
86 |
Zero |
| Princeton 500 |
43 |
Zero |
| Bond County 2 |
120 |
Zero |
| Duquoin CUSD 300 |
101 |
Zero |
| Rocton 140 |
102 |
Zero |
| Rochelle Twp. HSD 212 |
71 |
Zero |
| Rochelle CCSD 231 |
131 |
Zero |
| Byron 226 |
127 |
Zero |
| Oregon 220 |
104 |
Zero |
| Farmington Central 265 |
85 |
Zero |
| Porta 202 |
75 |
Zero |
| River Bend 2 |
71 |
Zero |
| Red Bud 132 |
73 |
Zero |
| Sparta 140 |
105 |
Zero |
| Southwestern 9 |
107 |
Zero |
| Staunton 6 |
87 |
Zero |
| Gillespie 7 |
81 |
Zero |
| Hamilton County 10 |
83 |
Zero |
| Midwest Central 191 |
85 |
Zero |
| Tuscola 301 |
86 |
Zero |
| West Carroll 314 |
99 |
Zero |
| Oakwood 76 |
64 |
Zero |
| Hoopeston 11 |
94 |
Zero |
| Westville 2 |
80 |
Zero |
| Beardstown 15 |
98 |
Zero |
| El Paso-Gridley 11 |
99 |
Zero |
| Murphysboro 186 |
137 |
Zero |
| Monticello 25 |
111 |
Zero |
| Paris-Union 95 |
74 |
Zero |
| Mt. Vernon Twp. 210 |
80 |
Zero |
| Mt. Vernon 80 |
109 |
Zero |
| Jasper County 1 |
101 |
Zero |
| Steger 194 |
128 |
Zero |
| Calumet City 155 |
77 |
Zero |
| North Boone 200 |
116 |
Zero |
| CCSD 93 Carol Stream |
294 |
Zero |
| East Maine SD 63 |
254 |
Zero |
| Lockport Township HS 205 |
205 |
Zero |
| |
|
|
| Above Teachers Total |
82,981 |
|
Comments (32)
March 28, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Dismissal, Harvard School Board, Harvard School District 50, Layoff
Here’s what’s happening re layoffs at Harvard School District 50:

Friday afternoon view of the Crosby Elementary School parking lot.
This responds to your March 17, 2011, Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”) request for “documents relating to the reasons for and date of any teachers’ or other certified personnel’s dismissals in 2009, 2010 and 2011.” The District has identified the following records as responsive to your request:
Notices of Non-Reemployment issued to the following first, second or third-year non-tenured teachers:
- Cassandra Vinci
- Dannielle Parrotte
- Yuh-Shiow Sheu
- Mark Rusk
- Katherine Senese
- Alberto Juarez
- Garrett Dore
- Angela Weaver
- Heather Davis
- Rachel Hockmeyer
- Jamie Saunders
- Efrain Gonzalez
- Maria Guzman
- Grecia Mapica Guevara
- Wendy Krepel
Notices of Dismissal issued to the following grant-funded, non-tenured teachers:
- Erin Thiede
- Tara Peterson
Notice of Dismissal issued to the Kristi Havlicek, a fourth-year, non-tenured teacher
Notice of Nonrenewal issued to Donna Joyce and Ms. Joyce’s 2010-2011 performance evaluation.
Notice of Dismissal, Resolution and Bill of Particulars issued to Dr. Peter Koehn, a tenured school psychologist.
With the exception of Ms. Joyce’s 2010-2011 performance evaluation and the home addresses listed on each notice, the District is providing you with copies of the above-referenced documents as a PDF.
= = = = =
The photo was taken about 2:30 Friday afternoon from the WeatherBug part of the Harvard School District’s web site.
Comments (4)
March 15, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Crystal Lake Grade School District, Crystal Lake Grade School District 47, Crystal Lake High School District 155, Harvard, Harvard School District 50, Larry Snow, Pension, Teacher, Teacher Contract, Teacher Negotiations, Teacher Pension, Teachers Union, Union

Larry Snow
Former Huntley School Board member Larry Snow has done a prodigious amount of research about school districts where teachers pay nothing for their pensions.
Those employed in the private sector pay into Social Security. But they also pay the entire cost of teachers’ pensions in many, many Illinois school districts.
Snow asks the following question:
“How loud would teachers howl if
they had to pay for other peoples’ Social Security?” (emphasis in the original)
Entitled,
“Illinois is Proof “Investing in Education” is Democrat Lipstick on Legalized Looting,”
Snow’s piece is published in The Champion today.
The guts of his column is summarized below:
“Two thirds of all of the teachers in the worst and poorly performing school districts either don’t pay a penny, or pay very little for their pensions…
“This pattern of abuse by teachers and union officials in the worst school districts is clear.
“The chart shows how a third of all teachers in Illinois, all in the bottom half of lousy to poorly performing districts, pay next to nothing or literally zero for their luxury-benefit pensions.”

A major goal of teacher union collective bargaining is to shift the required employee payment from teachers' pockets to those of the taxpaying public.
His thesis is “teachers unions systematically drain education resources.”
He points to “work rules” as “a polite way of depicting work tourniquets. They are designed to limit the normal flow of instruction to students.”
Then, he moves on to health insurance premiums, challenging readers to
“Try finding a teachers contract in Illinois where the teacher is paying 15% of his or her own individual health care premium.”
He returns to pensions, pointing out,
“Illinois School Code says teachers are to pay 9.4 % of their salary into the state’s pension. The chart below shows what is actually happening. And this is just among the bottom half of school districts.”
Pension Contributions by Teachers in Some Bottom-Half-Performing School Districts
|
District |
ACT Score |
% of
Pension
Paid |
Number
Teachers |
% with
Masters Degree |
AverageSalary / Yrs. Experience
|
| Cahokia |
16.0 |
0.4 % |
298 |
44 % |
$ 66,098 / 12 |
| Thornton Twp 205 |
16.6 |
Zero |
428 |
62 |
79,868 / 12 |
| Waukegan 60 |
16.8 |
Zero |
1,098 |
54 |
55,749 / 11 |
| Morton 201 |
16.9 |
Zero |
455 |
62 |
69,826 / 11 |
| Chicago |
17.3 |
2 % |
23,219 |
60 |
68,679 / 13 |
| Kankakee 111 |
17.5 |
Zero |
348 |
65 |
60,671 / 15 |
| Joliet 204 |
18.0 |
Zero |
340 |
65 |
68,553 / 12 |
| Round Lake 116 |
18.2 |
Zero |
387 |
58 |
64,133 / 13 |
| Rockford |
18.4 |
Zero |
1,843 |
70 |
66,771 / 15 |
| Decatur 61 |
18.4 |
Zero |
454 |
33 |
50,332 / 12 |
| Peoria 150 |
18.4 |
0.4 % |
988 |
53 |
55,736 / 14 |
| Crete Monee |
18.4 |
Zero |
340 |
42 |
58,350 / 10 |
| Danville 118 |
18.7 |
Zero |
382 |
48 |
59,694 / 13 |
| Valley View 365 |
19.0 |
Zero |
1,068 |
63 |
64,217 / 10 |
| Springfield |
19.1 |
0.4 % |
1,105 |
46 |
58,369 / 12 |
| Aurora West 129 |
19.1 |
Zero |
706 |
76 |
77,089 / 13 |
| East Peoria 309 |
19.2 |
Zero |
69 |
33 |
58,589 / 14 |
| Galesburg |
19.2 |
Zero |
281 |
49 |
54,016 / 14 |
| Bremen 228 |
19.2 |
Zero |
313 |
68 |
$ 83,963 / 12 |
| Freeport |
19.4 |
Zero |
317 |
45 |
50,802 / 12 |
| Elgin U-46 |
19.6 |
Zero |
2,332 |
68 |
69,551 / 13 |
| Rock Island |
19.6 |
Zero |
388 |
67 |
69,608 / 15 |
| Mattoon |
19.7 |
Zero |
225 |
55 |
49,186 / 12 |
| Collinsville |
19.8 |
Zero |
394 |
53 |
53,295 / 12 |
| Massac 1 |
19.9 |
Zero |
143 |
33 |
46,065 / 12 |
| Sterling |
19.9 |
Zero |
219 |
49 |
54,789 / 12 |
| Belvidere |
20.1 |
Zero |
531 |
56 |
61,263 / 12 |
| Moline 40 |
20.3 |
0.4 % |
461 |
69 |
71,644 / 16 |
| Quincy |
20.4 |
Zero |
436 |
54 |
47,161 / 14 |
| Harvard |
20.4 |
0.87 % |
149 |
56 |
52,859 / 12 |
| Dixon |
20.4 |
Zero |
179 |
70 |
60,172 / 15 |
| West Chicago |
Below
Average Elem. & Middle Schools |
Zero |
248 |
60 |
70,701 / 14 |
| Cook County 130 |
Zero |
289 |
52 |
52,836 / 13 |
| Dolton 148 |
1.4 % |
236 |
44 |
53,284 / 10 |
| Cicero 99 |
Zero |
738 |
42 |
59,086 / 10 |
| Joliet 86 |
Zero |
617 |
34 |
53,659 / 11 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Teachers Above |
42,024 |
|
$ 65,920 |
| Total Public School Teachers in Illinois |
132,502 |
|
Salary Avg. Weighted for No. of Teachers |
|
Percent of Above Teachers to Total in Illinois |
32 % |
|
Snow adds this local tidbit:
“Crystal Lake is served by two, above-average-performing districts, 155 and 47 with about a thousand (976) teachers. None contribute a penny for their pensions.
“You can add more districts such as this one to easily count over a third of all teachers in Illinois paying little to nothing.”
Comments (50)
March 03, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Alden-Hebron School District 19, Alden-Hebron Unit District 19, Barrington School District 220, Cary Elementary School District 26, Cary Grade School District, Crystal Lake Grade School District, Crystal Lake Grade School District 47, Crystal Lake High School District 155, District 200, District 26, District 300, District 47, Dues, Fox River Grove Grade School District 3, Harrison Grade School District 36, Harvard School District 50, Huntley School District 158, IEA, Illinois Education Association, Johnsburg School District, Marengo High School District 156, Marengo-Union Grade School District 165, McHenry Grade School District 15, McHenry High School District 156, Nippersink Elementary School District 2, Prairie Grove District 46, Richmond Burton High School District 157, Riley Grade School District 18, Teachers Union, Union, Union Dues, Wonder Lake, Woodstock School District 200
McHenry County Blog has surveyed school districts with major presences in McHenry County and discovered that union employees paid $3.8 million in dues during calendar year 2010.
The total amount was $3,825,572.
Contracts are typically for more than one year and most expenses would in contract negotiation year.
Most are from dues paid by teachers, but there are also office worker and school bus drivers.
Most go to the Illinois Education Association-National Education Association.
Part of the collective bargaining proposal made by Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker is to end mandatory union membership.
Illinois, of course, has laws that force all employees of a bargaining unit to pay dues.
The legislation would require that teacher union officials collect their own dues, rather than having as a payroll deduction, as is the case in all of the districts below.
To no one’s surprise, employees of the largest district examined, Carpentersville Unit District 300, paid the most dues. The total was over $1.1 million.
- Barrington Unit District 220 – $554,555
- Alden-Hebron Unit District 19 – $22,427
- Cary Grade School District 26 – $52,254
- Crystal Lake Grade School District 47 – 315,342
- Crystal Lake High School District 155 – $287,202
- Carpentersville Unit District 300 – $1,122,392
- Fox River Grove Grade School District 3 – $23,599
- Harvard Unit School District 50 – $96,745
- Huntley Unit School District 158 – $356,047
- Johnsburg Unit District 12 – $106,055
- Marengo-Union Grade School District 165 – $48,778
- Marengo High School District 154 – $30,005
- McHenry Grade School District 15 – $207,111
- McHenry High School District 156 – $109,331
- Prairie Grove Grade School District 46 – $10,863
- Richmond-Burton (Nippersink) Grade School District 2 – $59,429
- Richmond-Burton High School District 157 – $37,592
- Riley Grade School District 18 – $9,161
- Wonder Lake (Harrison) School District 36 – $13,249
- Woodstock Unit School District 200 – $372,595

Teachers walk picket line outside Huntley High School in 2008.
Comments (4)
February 05, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Harvard, Harvard School Board, Harvard School District 50, Special Ed, Special Election
These were posted below the article entitled,
Harvard School District Fires Psychologist who Complained about Special Ed Program to U.S. Department of Education
Here’s the second and most lengthy comment:
Currently, Harvard School District 50 is under audit by the Illinois State Board of Education concerning their policies and procedures concerning Special Education students within the District with an IEP. This information is freely available through the Illinois State Board of Education under the Freedom of Information Act.
I have fought this battle concerning IEP’s within the District, and the truth is, I don’t see things changing. This is not just an administration problem, but a problem that has spread throughout the District, including some faculty and staff who don’t know how to write, follow, or just plain ignore the legally binding document that an IEP is, and the legalities of the procedures behind it.
I don’t forsee things changing in Harvard anytime soon with the administration and the board that is in place.
Truthfully, what do a board of elected members know about Special Education law and procedures?
They rely on the Administration and the District lawyers to handle that kind of thing.
I have become knowledgeable enough in the area of Special Education to know that District 50 is pulling the wool over a lot of parents eyes when in comes to IEP’s and Special Education. I wish this would get more press than it is getting.
But what is a parent to do?
Sue the District? Takes money.
File a complaint with the State? They are already under audit for their policies and procedures.
The answer lies in banging your head against the wall each and every time you have to deal with the District concerning IEP’s. It feels better than actually dealing with the IEP.
Are the children in Harvard with IEP’s having their civil rights violated? Could be if they are not getting the “Free and Appropriate Education” they are entitled under law.
That means that their IEP is written to be the most “Appropriate” for them, including placement in special education programs that are suitable for them and necessary accommodations within “regular” and “special education” classrooms.
But even if those are written into the IEP, the District is bound by law to follow that IEP, and there is where a lot of the problem lies.
Did Koehn go about this the right way?
Not sure.
There obviously was more going on than just the “whistle blowing.”
Maybe he didn’t follow proper procedure within the District before contacting OCR. I’m not saying either way as I don’t know the whole situation.
But I do know that there is definately an issue concerning Special Education students in District 50.
Harvard Special Education parents…seek the knowledge you need to know to properly deal with this problem.
This is a systemic problem that is not likely to go away anytime soon.
As Mary said above, speak out against the problem. At least you can do that.
But that doesn’t necessarily bring change.
I’m not trying to be the pessimist, but just the parent who has the battle scars of the fight.
Here’s the one from Mary referred to above:
Gus (Philpott in a comment before) hit it on the head. But it is not only special education teachers that are subjected to retaliation when it comes to standing up and speaking out, this mind set is rampant across the system.
Those who stay, who are dedicated to their students and have not co-opted to the system learn to do a very delicate dance in order to maintain their integrity as well as their job.
We may not be able to fix the system from this blog, but we certainty can make a phone call, send an email, ask questions,express our opinions and let these board members know how you feel.
They are, according to the District 50 web site, which provides both email addresses as well as phone numbers:
- Ken Book: 815-943-3161/ kbook@owl.net
- Richard Stoxen: 815-943-6879 /stoxfarm@mc.net
- Roger Wilhort: 815-943-7691 /MSTRICK@mc.net
- Sharon McMillian:815-943-4653 /roger.wilhoit@ffic.com
- Rebecca Klien: 815-299-5272 /rklein@stans.net
- Diane Bird: 815-943-3690 bird-ddp@webtv.net
I was taught…when it is wrong and you do nothing, you are part of the wrong!
= = = = =
Thought this comment might be relevant enough to provide more prominence:
…as a side note, the e-mail addresses above are not correct. Not sure if the copy/paste did not work as intended, but all the information is available on the District website at http://www.cusd50.org/index.php/School-Board-alt/
Comments (3)
February 04, 2011
By: Cal Skinner
Category: Department of Education, Harvard, Harvard High School, Harvard Junior High School, Harvard School Board, Harvard School District 50, Peter Koehn, School Psychologist, Special Ed, Special Education
In December, the United States Department of Education’s Civil Rights Office (OCR) notified Dr. Peter Koehn that his complaints about the treatment of Special Education children met the criteria for an investigation.
Monday night the Harvard School Board dismissed whistle blower Koehn from his position as School Psychologist.
The clinical psychologist, who has hung his shingle out in Crystal Lake at Neal Psychological Specialties (815-477-4727), now intends to help parents of students with disabilities obtain the education that their children deserve.
Koehn complained that Harvard’s school system was discriminating against students in grade, junior high and high school when it changed IEP’s (Individual Education Programs) in the Fall of 2010, which led to a significant change in placement without following appropriate evaluation and placement procedures.
Department of Education Team Leader/Supervisory Attorney Aleeza Strubel stresses in her letter of December 3rd that the opening of an investigation “in no way implies that OCR has made a determination with regard to its merit.”
In a separate letter acknowledging a second Koehn complaint to the same office, Stubel informed him an investigation would be made of his complaint about being subjected “to retaliation after you objected to changes that the junior high school Principal made to students’ Individual Education Program (IEPs) during the summer of 2010. After you raised these objections, the Principal required to participate in a pre-disciplinary meeting on October 20, 2010, with the Superintendent.”
Comments (16)