McHenry County Blog

Subscribe

Archive for the ‘Pro-Choice’

What Do Dee Beaubien & Tammy Duckworth Really Believe about Abortion? The Personal PAC Questionnaire

October 30, 2012 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, David McSweeney, Dee Boreing, Endorsement, Extreme, Extremist, Joe Walsh, Personal PAC, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, Tammy Duckworth

After the deluge of publicity about how “extreme” Congressman Joe Walsh is on the abortion issue went unanswered, my frustration level grew so much that I posted the following on Capitol Fax Blog:

Cal Skinner – Monday, Oct 15, 12 @ 10:33 am:

Picture a bold Pro-Lifer’s response.

Run a video of a baby developing.

Say, “Not all of us are going to agree when this becomes a baby, but all of us are going to agree there is a baby before the baby is born.

“Tammy Duckworth believes that mothers should be able to abort their babies up until the day they are born.

“Now, that’s extreme.”

Run text along the bottom quoting what Duckworth’s told the Tribune: “Duckworth said she does not ’support any restrictions on a woman’s right to chose or her access to safe, affordable reproductive health services.”

Now, it would take a bold Pro-Life candidate to follow this advice and there have been none sighted in Illinois.

Something like this run against Pat Quinn during the last days of the campaign would have elected Bill Brady, I believe.

Dave McSweeney went in this direction in a mailing that got delivered on Saturday that can be seen here:

http://mchenrycountyblog.com/2012/10/14/mcsweeney-responds-to-beaubien-pounding-on-abortion-issue/

Also related to abortion, a Catholic Church in Crystal Lake went all in on Obama last weekend:

http://mchenrycountyblog.com/2012/10/15/crystal-lakes-st-thomas-parishioners-get-handout-like-none-they-have-ever-seen/

Below you will see the pro-abortion Personal PAC five-page questionnaire for legislative candidates. Personal PAC requires answers that agree with its positions in order to get an endorsement.

Take a read and see if you conclude that a Personal PAC-endorsed candidate has an “extreme” position on abortion.  Click on any page to enlarge it.




Some of the letter writers in the Chicago Tribune provide rebuttals to the attacks on Joe Walsh:

The letters supporting Joe Walsh don’t get put in a prominent location, but they did make the Tribune Monday. Click to enlarge.

Chicago Teachers Union Rewards Jack Franks

October 26, 2012 By: Cal Skinner Category: Chicago Teachers Union, CTU, Jack Franks, James Meeks, Pro-Choice

Just happened to look at the campaign disclosure page of unopposed Democrat State Rep. Jack Franks and found that the Chicago Teachers Union has donated $1,500.

It may just be coincidence that Franks got such a large contribution from Chicago in a race contested merely by a write-in candidate, but I can’t help remembering that when State Senator James Meeks had a voucher bill that would save state taxpayers $240 million.

Franks voted against it.

Most suburban Republicans understand that Chicago Schools are failing and something new is needed. Jack Franks, however, voted against allowing parents of 30,000 of the students in the worst high schools  to get money to spend on their children’s education in schools of their choice.  Franks is Pro-Choice on abortion, however.  Note Mike Tryon and Mark Beaubien voted, “Yes.”

The CTU is not a new supporter for Franks, as you can see here.

Why would someone in McHenry County vote against the possibility that mainly black and Latino teens in Chicago might finally be able to get decent educations?

Do Franks’ liberal supporters really know how reactionary he is on helping poor minorities?

Message of the Day – Mixed

October 10, 2012 By: Cal Skinner Category: David McSweeney, Dee Beaubien, Donna Kurtz, Message of the Day, Personal PAC, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, Sign

I see “Vote Pro-Life” yard signs popping up around the Crystal Lake area.

Usually they do not have a candidate sign next to them, which, it seems to me, minimizes the message.

After all, most people don’t know who the Pro-Life candidates are.

And there are actually candidates who are avowedly Pro-Choice.

In the Crystal Lake area, that includes State Rep. candidate Dee Beaubien (Ind.-Madigan), who has received significant campaign support from Personal PAC, the most radical pro-abortion outfit in the country.

Personal PAC posted endorsements for three County Board members prior to the March primary election:

  • Donna Kurtz
  • Jim Roden
  • Scott Summers

That brings us to our mixed message of the day:

Donna Kurtz and Pro-Life signs on McHenry Avenue in Crystal Lake.

Madigan Doesn’t Wait for Personal PAC to Launch Abortion Attack

September 11, 2012 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, David McSweeney, Dee Beaubien, Mike Madigan, Personal PAC, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, Uncategorized

Late last week Democrat Mike Madigan’s campaign folks unleashed the first attempt to drive people away from Republican David McSweeney using the abortion issue.

This is the address side of the Democratic Party of Illinois mailing on behalf of Dee Beaubien (Ind.-Madigan). It uses the issue of abortion to try to drive voters in Beaubien’s direction.

Most observers thought that it would be the pro-abortion Personal PAC that would do the heavy lifting on this topic.

According to the headline, Dave McSweeney’s position on abortion is “Unspeakable.”

But the Madigan strategists must think the issue needed playing sooner than Personal PAC.

Personal PAC is known for charging, late in the campaign, that Republican Pro-Life candidates want to put women who have abortions in jail.

 

Dave McSweeney Distributes Pro-Life Comparison Piece Showing No Endorsements for Kent Gaffney at Catholic Church

March 18, 2012 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, Danielle Rowe, Dave McSweeney, Kent Gaffney, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church

Crystal Lake's St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church is the location from which this campaign piece was retrieved.

So, what do you do on the morning of the Sunday before election day?

State Rep. candidate David McSweeney had volunteers handing out the piece you see below at at least one Catholic Church in Crystal Lake.

Probably at all Catholic and other presumed Pro-Life congregations as well.

St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church in Crystal Lake is the location where a friend of McHenry County Blog  found the the handout you see below on the family vehicle.

This piece comparing the positions on abortion of Dave McSweeney and Kent Gaffney were distributed in church parking lots.

Abortion is obviously a hot button issue for many, as the third candidate in the race, Danielle Rowe has told me. When she goes door-to-door that question is asked more than any other.

Chicago Sun-Times Defends Amanda’s Choice Not to Abort

September 04, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, Amanda Schulten, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life

Friday's Chicago Sun-Times Article.

Marengo’s Amanda Schulten has decided not to kill her two babies, who are conjoined at the heart.

No abortion for her.

Even though her doctor advised her to have an abortion.

A devout Catholic (joining the Church just this Easter), the mother has decided to let God be in control.

Let go and let God, so to speak.

As her blog puts it,

One Heart

Two Souls

The Chicago Sun-Times ran a large article, complete with photography of a very pregnant 21-year old, on Friday.  It’s title was,

Faith in the face of adversity

Woman carrying conjoined twins tells

them in poem, ”My soul will never leave you’

This Sunday, there is an editorial in defense of the right to chose an abortion…

or not:

Exercising right not

to choose abortion

“Pro-choice means pro-choice, not pro-abortion,” the editorial writer states.

One might observe that Pro-Life means that a mother with that opinion wants her baby or babies delivered alive.

As Amanda puts it in a Friday post,

“I will do anything for them. And that means giving them a chance to live.”

What does that make of those who disagree with that position?

Here’s McHenry County Blog’s Thursday article:

Marengo Mother About to Give Birth to Twins

with One Heart – “One Heart – Two Souls”

Amanda Schulten

Commenting on her being a single mother, new Catholic Amanda wrote Friday,

“…seeing that people think I’m a cafeteria catholic (just had to add). I had no faith before this and now look I have God in my life…

“My fiance and I were planning a wedding but unfourtnatley we don’t have the money nor time as of right now.”

The “Safe Haven” Shield Pro-Choice Politicians Use in the Abortion Argument

August 21, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, Baby, Fetus, Jim Edgar, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, Safe Haven

This Safe Haven sign is in front of Crystal Lake's City Hall.

There is a concept used in campaigns that could be called a “political shield.”

Abortion being a distasteful subject not often discussed in private or public is, nevertheless, one that motivates political activists and, at least on the pro-choice side of the equation, contributors.

So what do those on the Pro-Choice side of the spectrum use to soften the image of the aborted “fetus,” as they would label it.

In the 1990′s, it was adoption.

Pro-Choice politicians like Jim Edgar pushed adoption.

At least his wife Brenda did.

For some, the abstract concept of “a woman’s right to choose” is outright racism. I learned that firsthand when I heard a white female state representative, whom I respected on all other spectra, say during a debate on a bill that was about abortion (although not on the surface), “They’re too many black babies.”

Not that I am suggesting that Brenda Edgar was a racist. Neither are probably most other who label themselves “Pro-Choice.”

I think Brenda was just trying to soften her husband’s image of being a supporter of abortion.

Then another “shield” entered the political firmament.

Its warm and fuzzy name was “Safe Haven.”

The idea was that women who gave birth, but decided they could not care for their newborn, would be able to hand them over to someone officially designated to take and provide immediate care without fear of being charged with child abandonment.

No need to risk criminal prosecution by disposing of a baby in a garbage bin.

Not a bad idea.

But not a big idea.

Not big results.

69 babies saved in ten years, according to the Save Abandoned Babies Foundation.

Worth doing, but not something that would made a dent in the number of abortions.

While state statistics for the Safe Haven program are apparently easy to calculate, when I tried to find the number of abortions in Illinois in the last ten years at the Centers for Disease Control (and, now, “Prevention”) are not available. The most recent abortion number was for 2007, released last November.

They total 458,660 from 1998-2007.

The Chicago Tribune though the Safe Haven program was worth a front page story.

Strangely, all years did not agree with the statistics I later found at the Illinois Department of Public Health web site. The state statistics appear below:

  • 2000 – 45,884
  • 2001 – 46,546
  • 2002 – 46,945
  • 2003 – 42,228
  • 2004 – 43,537
  • 2005 – 43,409
  • 2006 – 46,467
  • 2007 – 45,298
  • 2008 – 47,717
  • 2009 – 46,077

The Illinois DPH total from 2000-2009 was 454,108 abortions.  (The CDC and IDPH figures do not match for 2003. Can’t tell you why.)

Dividing the 69 babies saved by the Safe Haven program by the 458,660 babies who died from abortions over a ten-year period reported by the CDC equals 0.00015%.

69 divided by the IDPH decade figure of 454,108 is 0.000152.

Both are truly a rounding errors.

Not that the results were not worth the effort.

But featuring 69 babies saved when over 450,000 were lost makes me wonder why the Safe Haven program was worth a front page story in Saturday’s Chicago Tribune.

With not a word about the over 450,000 babies who did not make it out of the womb alive.

The McHenry County Fair – Political Angles

August 06, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Barb Wheeler, Brent Smith, Don Manzullo, Eric Peterson, Glenda Miller, Jack Franks, Jim Young, Joe Walsh, Libertarian, Libertarian Party, McHenry County Auditor, McHenry County Citizens for Choice, McHenry County Democats, McHenry County Democratic Central Committee, McHenry County Fair, McHenry County Republican Party, McHenry County Republicans, McHenry County Reublican Central Committee, McHenry County Right To Carry Association, McHenry County Right-to-Life, McHenry County Sheriff, McHenry County Sheriff's Department, McHenry County Sportsman Association, Pam Palmer, Peter's Net, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life, Toby Levin

While the teen were exploring other parts of the McHenry County Fair on Friday, I went looking for things political.

Democratic Party State Rep. Jack Franks’ tent was first.  It was closest to the free parking.

Jack Franks staffer Parker Happ mans the Jack Franks tent, smiling as he did last year when my photo was good enough to end up on his Facebook’s front page.

Then,  I saw the Sheriff’s Department’s Crime Stoppers Trailer.

This Sheriff’s Department trailer was parked behind the arena.

The McHenry County Sheriff’s booth was at the front of the first building I entered, although Sheriff Keith Nygren had not yet arrived.

The Sheriff’s Department has a double booth just as one enters one of the display buildings.

McHenry County Citizens for Choice was way around the corner.

Marian Michaels, Dee Many and Toby Levin were staffing/visiting the McHenry County Citizens for Choice booth.

The McHenry County Republican Party booth was down the aisle to the right. My second time around I found Jack Franks’ staffer conversing with the folks behind the table.

Eric Peterson, Glenda Miller and Pam Palmer talk with Jack Franks’ staffer Parker Happ.

I found the Sheriff’s Department had a second booth location to the right of the main one.

This McHenry County Sheriff’s booth was unmanned when I walked by.

In the next building, the Libertarian Party booth was the first I saw.

Jim Young, who ran for State Rep. as a Libertarian, was asking people to put pennies into the jar which best represented their beliefs about the national debt.

Into which jar would you put a penny supplied by the Libertarian Party?

Most pennies were in the “Cut Spending” jar.

Next door was the best political story.

The negative reaction of a modeling agency, which was across the aisle, and a County Fair Official’s reported reaction to a complaint was the best story I found.  The complaining booth workers got another location.

The booth was called “Peter’s Net.” Those in it were clearly Catholics and they were explaining how Catholics were Pro-Life.

There were models of how large a baby was at various lengths of gestitation. This man was closely examining the part of the display at the early end of pregnancy.

Here’s a closer look at the models.

I particularly like the baby in God’s hands.

The booth renter across the aisle, described as a “modeling agency” complained about the medical models to Fair Officials. One came and, I’m told, said that the display might not be allowed next year.

The models at the other Pro-Life booth.

Since I vividly remember a similar display from 2000 at the McHenry County Right-To-Life organization, I have a hard time understanding such logic, assuming the story that reached my ears was correct.

It certainly makes no economic sense for the Fair, since another Catholic group, renting three or four spaces–as many as the Sheriff’s Department–also had in utero models.

Maybe it was the message on the button saying, “It’s a child, not a choice” that bothered the folks across the aisle or maybe the models were drawing too much attention from the young girls the complaining booth was targeting.

Just around the corner was the McHenry County Democratic Central Committee’s booth.

Terry Kappel and John Darger were staffing the Democrats booth.

They had an intimidating American history quiz that they were encouraging people to take.  I was told Jack Franks wouldn’t take it.

This “Hands Off my Medicare” sign was on the side of the Democrats’ booth.

I hesitated, read the questions on the front page and figured by 7th and 8th grade American history classes would stand me in good stead.  Then I started checking off the best answer.  I did find until I got to the national debt question.  It asked when the first debt ceiling had been passed.  That was not in any of the American history classes I took.  I won’t ruin the quiz. Suffice is to say that was my only wrong answer.

As I continued my political tour of the McHenry County Fair, I found a second large Pro-Life booth.

“Life is Sacred” is the largest print one sees as one approaches this booth from the south.

Young girls were looking at a display of baby booties and shoes called “Little Soles.”

“Little Soles” is the title of this Pro-Life display..

This is the other booth in which I found the in utero models seen above.

There is also a big banner proclaiming “Life Is Sacred” with a Bible quote.

The booth tee shirt.

Right across the aisle was the booth of the McHenry County Sportsman’s Association and the McHenry County Right to Carry Association.

With Illinois’ being the last state in the union where individuals are not allowed to carry firearms to protect themselves, the petition signatures gathered in past years may have been the reason that Jack Franks’ flipped from being opposed to being favor.

Barbara Wheeler, the only Republican candidate to have announced for the 64th State Representative District, talks with Anthony Lopez President of the McHenry County Sportsman’s Association at the booth his group and the McHenry County Right to Carry Association sponsored at the County Fair.

President Anthony Lopez was standing out front talking to Barb Wheeler, who was helping staff the booth. His wife Laura Rakers was behind the table with Richard Pere.

I went looking for Congressman Joe Walsh’s outpost.

Erin Westphal drew tent staffing duty for Congressman Joe Walsh.  At the Wauconda Town Hall Meeting, she was one bringing the microphone to those who want to ask questions or make statements.

It was on the midway in a corner tent.

I doubled back to the building with the Sheriff’s display in hopes of finding Sheriff Keith Nygren and was rewarded by his presence.

Sheriff Keith Nygren talking to two members of his staff.

I made another circuit and found Congressman Don Manzullo’s booth. Former Wonder Lake resident Marilyn Davis was behind the table.

Kathleen Davis was staffing Congressman Don Manzullo’s booth.

As I left the building, Nunda Township Republican Chairman Brent Smith and Sheriff Nygren were having a conversation.

On the way out, I saw John O’Neill, an announced candidate for McHenry County Board staffing the Ray Chevrolet tent.

Barb Wheeler State Rep. Fund Raiser Successful

July 30, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, Barb Wheeler, Barbara Wheeler, Bonnie Quirke, Brent Smith, Bryan Winter, Campaign Contributions, Campaign Finance, Fund Raiser, Fund Raising, Irene Napier, Joe Gottemoller, Kent Gaffney, Mike Chmiel, Mike Shorten, Nancy Gonsiorek, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life

About a fourth of the crowd at the rural Nunda Township estate that hosted Barbara Wheeler's fund raiser.

An impressive crowd turned out for McHenry County Board member Barb Wheeler’s fund raiser for her State Rep. campaign.

It's been a long time since I dipped into Lake County politics. Wheeler has no choice since just over 50% of the new 64th District is across the county line. Bryan Winter, who is running for Lake County State's Attorney, was accompanied by his wife Judge Diane Winter. Former McHenry County State's Attorney candidate Dan Regna can be seen in the foreground. He was not the only one from Lake County present.

From those attending, I concluded that she will be the favorite of most of the McHenry County part of the 64th District that she seeks to represent.

Donna Kurtz chatted with Duane Sokolosky, an Algonquin Township GOP Precinct Committeeman.

There were candidates galore, including several thinking seriously about running for County Board, incumbents running for re-election, plus those interested in Grafton Township governmental slots.  Of significance is that none of Grafton Township is within the 64th District.

McHenry County Board member Tina Hill visited with Crystal Lake Grade School Board member Nancy Gonsiorek.

The idea of fund raisers is to raise money, of course.

Newly-appointed State Rep. Kent Gaffney and his wife Elizabeth conversed with Right to Life leaders Bonnie Quirke (Lake County) and Irene Napier (McHenry County). Like Wheeler's, Gaffney's district straddles the Lake-McHenry County line.

There was no set price, so there is no way anyone outside of Wheeler’s campaign knows how much was contributed, but there are several observations that can be made.

Barb Wheeler greets McHenry County Circuit Judge Mike Chmiel.

A successful fund raiser has to keep down expenses. The private home eliminated the need to rent a hall.

In this view of people attending Barb Wheeler's fund raiser I see former Crystal Lake City Council candidate Mike Shorten on the far left.

Beer, wine, soft drinks and water were provided, as were Italian beef sandwiches. There were some other light snacks.

How late did the party, which started at 6, last? This was my last shot. You seen Nunda Township Republican Party Chairman Brent Smith and Joe Gottemoller well after sunset.

The execution of the event pretty much guaranteed the net would be as large as possible.

Although it doesn’t make much of a story, those who stay home and send money can increase the total contributed at events like this.

Mark Beaubien State Rep. Replacement Kent Gaffney Identified as “Social Moderate” in Daily Herald

July 02, 2011 By: Cal Skinner Category: Abortion, Bob Cook, Civil Unions, Dee Beaubien, Gene Dawson, Kent Gaffney, Mark Beaubien, Mike Tryon, Pro-Choice, Pro-Life

Guess I didn’t read Eric Peterson’s Daily Herald article about Kent Gaffney’s replacing State Rep. Mark Beaubien carefully enough.

In my article on the House Appropriations Committee Budget Director’s advancement from staff member to state legislator, I missed the apparent fact that he is a social moderate.

Kent Gaffney

The Daily Herald reports Gaffney “does believe government should stay out of what ought to be citizens’ personal choices about their lives.”
Beabien’s wife Dee said Kent was “a moderate like Mark.” The reported said Beaubien believed “some in the Lake County Republican contingent were hoping for someone more conservative on social issues.’

Beaubian was a consistent opponent of restrictions on abortion and voted for the civil union bill that just became effective June 1st.

In McHenry County, about twenty-five couples filed civil union paperwork with the McHenry County Clerk in June.

The article also says Gaffney moved from Springfield, where he was born, “only a few years ago.”

Although the vote among the three pro-life Republican Party leaders was not taken in public, it was McHenry County Republican Chairman and State Rep. Mike Tryon’s almost 50% vote combined with the tiny weighted vote of Barrington Township and 8th Congressional District State Central Committeeman Gene Dawson that created the necessary majority to appoint Gaffney.

Assuming that Gaffney is as pro-choice as Beaubien was, he will have the support of Personal PAC. Personal PAC specializes in hiring phone banks to call every woman in a legislative district asking if they are “pro-choice.” Turning out that “base” consists of the guts of the political action committee’s campaign.

That strategy can work in suburban districts when more than two social conservatives run for the same legislative office.

I speculated early on that a female pro-choice candidate from Crystal Lake could win the primary election to replace Beaubien.

Besides having the support of Personal PAC, she would, of course, have had the five percentage point advantage. Research over my political career has led me to believe that a woman has a five percentage point advantage over a man in the Northwest suburbs.

Gaffney, of course, will not have that advantage.