McHenry County Blog

Subscribe

Archive for the ‘Rob Bush’

Chris Krug on Value of Township Government

April 19, 2010 By: Cal Skinner Category: Forrest Hare, Grafton Township, Grafton Township Meeting, Grafton Township Trustee, John Rung, Nunda Township, Nunda Township Road Commissioner, Porten's Subdivision, Rob Bush, Township Administrator, Township Officials of Illinois, Township Road Commissioner

Sunday Northwest Herald Executive Editor Chris Krug wrote of taking some heat from a reader who criticized him in a letter to his boss John Rung.

In response, Krug said he was going to list the benefits of township government.

What followed was nine empty lines.

Of the six comments when I wrote this at 2 yesterday afternoon, most were favorable to Krug’s viewpoint.

The final one, from “hblarson” read,

“Chris: The township is the most democratic of our American institutions. To do away with the township is to admit We the People are incapable of maintaining a democratic form of government. One way of looking at the issue is: If residents of a township are unhappy with their town government, they, as electors, are empowered to change it.”

Larson, alas, is remembering the past.

Back in 1969. township electors indeed had power.

They had the power of setting the budget.

Porten's Subdivision with area in the flood plain shown. Map taken from the new GIS web site.

That year, Porten’s Subdivision in Nunda Township next to the Fox River, which had private roads the Nunda Township Road Commissioner would not repair because, well, because they were private, went on the war path.

They packed the township meeting and lowered each line item in the road commissioner’s budget to $1.

What they didn’t know was the township road commissioner’s salary was in the Town Fund.

So, the road commissioner got paid, but didn’t have the money to do any work.

That same year, electors supporting reform-assessor Forrest Hare took control of the Algonquin Township meeting  at Eastview Grade School on Route 62.

The pesky homeowners, who were fed up with being assessed by the county supervisor of assessments at a higher level than elsewhere in McHenry County, inserted $500 in the budget to sue for equity.

$500 was a big number then.

The Algonquin Township attorney managed to spend the $500 without filing suit, so nothing substantive came of the action.

Except…

Except, township officials asked the Illinois General Assembly to change state law so uppity citizens would have no say on the budget.

Instead all the decisions henceforth would be made by the township auditors (the name changed later to “trustees”).

So commenter Larson, direct democracy died about 1970.

Grafton Township meeting as seen from the western part of the gym before the momentous meeting began.

Annual Town Meetings now have very little substance to them, despite the Grafton Township exception this year.

In fact, it would surprise me not one bit if the Township Officials of Illinois lobbyists were not at this very moment trying to change township law to remove the requirement that voters have to approve borrowing money to build township buildings.

That would overturn the law made by 2nd Appellate Justices in the Grafton Township case last year.

Ancel Glink Partner Robert Bush

Just this year, some Grafton Township citizens petitioned to have votes on whether to fire the township attorney, Ancel Glink.

Ancel Glink Partner Rob Bush ruled that township electors did not have that power, so the question could not be put on the Annual Town Meeting agenda.

So sad, attorneys are hired and fired only by township boards.

Firing the new Township Administrator was also ruled to be none of the township electors’ business.

And that revolutionary idea of requiring Robert’s Rules of Order at all township board meetings, well, in that matter, too, the electors were irrelevant.  (Now, Grafton township meetings often resemble a free for all, the board having set themselves from Robert’s Rules of Order.)

So, Mr. or Mrs. Larson, the next time you try to defend township government because it is some Athenian democratic ideal, please don’t.

Just as “American Pie” relates the “day the music died,” direct democracy died in township government decades ago.

Now, township boards run the show pretty much as city councils do.  And as county boards do.  And as school boards.

Nothing very special about the way townships are governed.

Tidal Wave of Opposition Overwhelms Trustees’ Desire for New Grafton Township Offices

April 14, 2010 By: Cal Skinner Category: Aileen Seedorf, Annual Town Meeting, Barbara Murphy, Betty Zirk, Don Drzal, Don Glogovsky, Grafton Township, Grafton Township Administrator, Grafton Township Hall, Grafton Township Meeting, Grafton Township Supervisor, Grafton Township Trustee, Harriet Ford, Huntley High School, Huntley School Board, Jack Freund, Jeff Thorsen, Jim Kearns, John Rossi, Keri-Lyn Krafthefer, Linda Moore, No More Taxes, Pam Fender, Paul Troy, Rick Lueth, Rob Bush, Robert LaPorta, Steve Harlfinger, Township, Township Administrator, Township Hall, Township Road Commissioner, Township Supervisor, Township Trustee

This Huntley High School Gym was packed to the rafters--over 700 people--with several rows of chairs in front before the Annual Town Meeting began. Certainly this meeting was the largest Annual Town Meeting in McHenry County I've seen since 1966.

Township Attorney Keri-Lyn Krafthefer, partner of the law firm Ancel Glink. Citizens petitioned for a Annual Town Meeting vote on whether to fire the firm, but another Ancel Glink lawyer, Rob Bush, ruled the people did not have that power, so that motion was not listed no the meeting agenda.

With over 700 registered voters in attendance, electors at the Annual Town Meeting overwhelmingly refused to follow the script laid out by Ancel Glink partner Keri-Lyn Krafthefer.

There were so many people in attendance that the 700 pink ballots designed by Township Administrator Pam Fender ran out.

About ten people stood on the sidelines as a result of the slight miscalculation.

They were told if there were ever a close vote, their vote would count.

They were not happy campers.

But none of the votes were close and none were taken by paper ballot.

There were so many people that the meeting did not start until after 7:30.

T-Shirted Grafton Township activists like Loretta Wuich passed out "poop" sheets as people were entering the Huntley High School Gym. The huge number of people could not be processed in time for the meeting to start at its advertised 7 PM beginning.

The opponents to the Trustees’ position clearly outmaneuvered the proponents.

On the way in people in bright green (they look yellow to me, but I’m color blind) tee-shirts saying,

“NO MORE TAXES,”

handed out a one-page explanation of what the meeting was all about…from the opponents’ viewpoint, of course.

Huntley Police were out in force. No problem occasioned their services to be required, except for traffic control getting out onto Harmony Road.

The Huntley Police, including its Chief were visible throughout the night and quite helpfully had flashing lights to slow down Harmony Road traffic as hundreds of cars left one by one after the meeting.

Most of the nine intricately worded resolutions written by the Trustee’s lawyer were ignored as it became obvious that opponents to the Township Trustees’ desire for new offices were not in control of the only form of direct democracy left in Illinois.

The test vote came when Jim

Newly-appointed Township Clerk Harriet Ford swears in Jim Kearns as Annual Town Meeting Moderator.

Kearns overwhelming was elected Moderator of the meeting.

My guess is that about 80% of the audience voted for him.

Next came a motion to do first what Ancel Glink put last on the agenda, a motion proposed by Township Road Commissioned Jack Freund to “unwind” (undo) the sale of the township hall to the Grafton Township Road District.

A motion was made to make the last first and it passed overwhelmingly without a paper ballot.

The desires of Township Road Commissioner Freund were explained by his attorney Pat Coen and after its combination with the sale of the Haligus Road property—the subject of three other resolutions—was split, that reversal of the past Supervisor John Rossi Board action was accomplished.

Trustees Betty Zirk and Rob LaPorta were sitting front and center next to Pam Fender, who did not get the opportunity to present the visual presentation she had prepared.

Six irrelevant resolutions that were intended to be considered first were then almost summarily disposed of. Among them were ones ratify the unlawful sale of the Town Hall to the Road District.

“Hot button issues should not rule the day,” Diane Ayers said.  “Maybe by leaving this at the end of the agenda some of the tempers will cool, so we can have a reasonable discussion.”  Ayers is a Democratic Party precinct committeeman.

Numerous attempts to slow down the meeting were made by those supporting the Trustees’ desires.

District 158 Board member Don Drzal calling for a paper ballot.

More and more mainly older residents left the meeting confident that their side was winning the day.

District 158 School Board member Paul Troy calling for a paper ballot.

District 158 School Board members Don Drzal and Paul Troy, at different times, tried to slow down the meeting by requiring a paper ballot.

Neither succeeded.

“This sounds like the township meetings,” Don Glogovsky, a Sun City man who ran for township trustee, interjected.

“Let’s continue with the agenda and do away with all the minutia and let democracy prevail.”

Opponents of unlawful action taken by the previous townshp board win a vote. Electors are holding up numbered and padded ballots intended to be used in a paper count. (Click to enlarge any photo.)

The first Haligus Road property resolution would have ratified the unlawful purchase. It was voted down. There was no question as to the outcome, although one supporter of the Trustees wanted to delay resolution until the next meeting.

His suggestion was met with a chorus of ‘No’s.”

A third school board member, Aileen Seedorf addressed the motion:

“They’re trying to ratify what they did.” (If you want to do that, vote ‘Yes.’  If not, then, Vote ‘No.’”

Before the meeting Ancel Glink attorney Rob Bush confers with Township Trustee Rob LaPorta with Trustee Barbara Murphy seen on the right.

The second Ancel Glink attorney at the meeting, Rob Bush, explained people who want to approve the purchase should vote in favor.

‘If you don’t want to take the deed, you should vote, ‘No.’”

The vote was not even close.

“Is this the way Christ would want it?” a man from the far end of the bleachers asked.

The next Haligus Road resolution would have the Trustees offer the property back to the Village of Lake in the Hills for the price the township paid, about $99,500. The motion carried with, it seemed, both sides’ support.

Both Huntley School Board member Aileen Seedorf and Crystal Lake City Councilman Jeff Thorsen were sitting in this section of the gym, a place where supporters of the Trustees were clustered.

The final motion would have the Trustees sell the property if Lake in the Hills did not want to buy it back. The motion was amended to require that the sale would have to be for at least $99,400.

Crystal Lake City Councilman Jeff Thorsen, sitting among a stronghold of Trustees’ supporters, observed,

“I don’t see anything here that that makes (the motions) mutually exclusive.”

During discussion, one man said, “Any price that’s market value should be acceptable.”

The amendment was adopted requiring the $99,500 payment, which Peter Hoffman figured would be about $36,000 an acre.

Prior to some votes, opponents of the Township Trustees' plan to obtain new township offices held up signs saying, "Yes" or "No."

The amended motion passed overwhelmingly.

Except for giving the Township Road Commissioner the right to sell some surplus property, that pretty much ended the meeting. It was after 9:30 and people were leaving in droves.

Afterward I asked each Trustee the same question:

“What now?”

Gerry McMahon, who had been most out front in his desire for the township to have new offices, said,

“I don’t know. (We) have to digest it first and then proceed with bankruptcy…maybe.”

This Grafton Township Elector confronted Township Trustee Rob LaPorta after the meeting was adjourned.

Betty Zirk’s reply?

“Nothing.”

As I was approaching Rob LaPorta, a man was berating him, telling him he got $100 a meeting for (doing less than a stellar job).

“Who are you serving?”

he said in a loud voice, using a barn yard epitaph to LaPorta’s reply.

“Who is this Bozo?” LaPorta asked.

“We don’t do anything behind closed doors,” I heard LaPorta say.

Lake in the Hills Trustee Steve Harlfiner, who lost the role of Moderator to Kearns, approached the cluster, saying, “Good luck selling (the property).”

This unhappy taxpayers told Trustee Barb Murphy that Linda Moore would not have been elected if the Trustees had not decided to spend $3.5 million on a new township hall without asking the voters.

“Linda Moore wouldn’t be in office if you hadn’t bought that building,” a second man said.

“We went by the advice we were given,” LaPorta replied.

“We made mistakes,” Trustee Barb Murphy, standing nearby, conceded.

“If you hadn’t tried to get that three and a half million dollar building, Linda wouldn’t have been elected,” the second mean reiterated.

I asked Murphy what was next.

“We can unwind,” a position she was the first Trustee to suggest last November.

You'll see me wearing a tee shirt like this one being wore by Rick Lueth at the Grafton Township meeting at the Crystal Lake TEA Party on Route 14 in front on Best Buy from 3-6:30 this Thursday afternoon.

When I got to talk to the acknowledged leader of the Trustees, LaPorta told me,

“We’re going to follow what was completed tonight and get the township processes to run smoothly.”

As I was walking out the meeting with two folks I was taking home, I asked Fender if I could have a commemorative ballot.

I had already been given an extra large tee-shirt saying,

“No More Taxes,”

which folks will see me wearing this Thursday at the Crystal Lake TEA (Taxed Enough Already) at the corner of Route 14 and Main Street.

“That’s the most fraudulent meeting I even saw in my entire life,” the Township Administrator remarked.

The separation of powers suit that Township Supervisor Linda Moore filed against the four trustees is scheduled for arguments during the second week of May before the same judge, Michael Caldwell, who issued the ruling that stopped the new township hall dead in its tracks.

Grafton Township Announces Intent to Violate to Open Meetings Act

March 12, 2010 By: Cal Skinner Category: Ancel Glick, Grafton Township, Open Meetings Act, Rob Bush, Robert Bush

Here it is, right on the official Grafton Township web site:

Announcement about excluding the non-voting public from the Grafton Township Annual Meeting, as of 12:45 PM on Friday, March 12th. Click to enlarge.

Only registered voters may attend (and press), you will need to show some form of ID and your name will be matched to our County voters registration roles.”  (Emphasis added.)

Ancel Glick attorney Robert Bush

Guess whoever made the decision to put that up on the web site didn’t have an adequate understanding of the requirements of the Open Meetings Act.

Last night at the regular Grafton Township Board meeting, Ancel Glick partner Rob Bush disabused the trustees of any notion that they might be able to keep the non-registered public out:

“It is a public meeting so anyone who wants to come can come.”

Guess it’s time to change the web site.

Maybe it will be changed by the time you read this.